Jump to content

  • Welcome to the eG Forums, a service of the eGullet Society for Culinary Arts & Letters. The Society is a 501(c)3 not-for-profit organization dedicated to the advancement of the culinary arts. These advertising-free forums are provided free of charge through donations from Society members. Anyone may read the forums, but to post you must create a free account.

Stoves and Ovens: Wolf? Thermador? Bluestar? Viking?

cfbuchanan

By cfbuchanan
in Kitchen Consumer

 Share

Recommended Posts

CentralMA

CentralMA

Posted
Posted

Thanks for all the responses. Some good questions here.

 

Incinerating a cow? I might need a bigger hood over the range. How often do we wok? If we had the heat output we might a little bit more. 

 

I've been doing the majority of the renovations on the house myself. We've gone low cost in some areas with the expectation that we could put those savings into some upgrades. 

Lower cost: Ikea kitchen cabinets, bathroom cabinets (got creative there), bathroom sink. "Splurged" on some Ikea undercounted lighting, wifi enabled. Local builders store shower pan and surround, Did the plumbing modifications myself, with the exception of the gas line extension (safety). Haggled for best deals on the other appliances, did pretty well there. Lots of painting, interior renovations, etc. Possibilities of a large deck that'll hang off the back of the house, maybe 300sqft. All said lots of changes, but not so much money involved. 

 

That said, there are $$$ in the bucket for the range that I'd like to have in the house. It'll (hopefully) be my last one. 

 

If you've ever worked in a well equipped restaurant kitchen you'll understand that the power burners are the ones most used. Makes fast and easy work of cooking, with all of the adjustments you need.  

 

I'm thinking I could be happy with the base RCS, 15k burners. Going down the rabbit hole of mumkin's links it looks like with a little bit of chicanery and a couple of hundred dollars I could save eight hundred and have higher output.

 

Still looking for input....I've not placed the order as yet.

 

Thanks all.

dscheidt

dscheidt

Posted
Posted
5 hours ago, weinoo said:

Do you really need 22K for a home kitchen? What are you , incinerating a cow?

 

I have a 20K btu burner on my range (a GE, couldn't quite convince my wife to spend the money on anything that expensive.  The feature I found most attractive about the BS is fitting a full sized sheet pan in the oven.)  The difference between 15 and 20K is substantial.  It gets used for things that don't necessary require it, but it makes them faster -- a pan sauce, or similar reductions, for instance.  It also makes boiling water faster. 

 

Not everyone cooks like this, my wife routinely puts water on to boil and sets the burner on medium.  It's an effort to keep from turning the burner up, and putting a cover on the pot, let me tell you. 

  • Like 1
weinoo

weinoo

Posted
Posted (edited)

As the wonderful cook @liuzhou has mentioned elsewhere, when the question was about home wok burners, basically no one in China has a burner anywhere near the equivalent of a wok burner in their home.  

 

How much time (provided you don't burn the shit out of it, or evaporate it completely) is someone saving making a pan sauce because she has a 22K BTU burner on her stove?

 

12 hours ago, CentralMA said:

If you've ever worked in a well equipped restaurant kitchen you'll understand that the power burners are the ones most used. Makes fast and easy work of cooking, with all of the adjustments you need.  

 

You're not in a restaurant kitchen; you're home, where cooking ought be pleasurable, not performed as if you're in the weeds.

 

And yes, I've worked in a restaurant kitchen. Personally, a 24" fridge would drive me crazy; in our tiny NYC apartment, I was very adamant with our architect about wanting a 33" full depth fridge, and got one.

Edited by weinoo (log)
  • Like 4

Mitch Weinstein aka "weinoo"

Tasty Travails - My Blog

My eGullet FoodBog - A Tale of Two Boroughs

Was it you baby...or just a Brilliant Disguise?

Dr. Teeth

Dr. Teeth

Posted
Posted (edited)
16 hours ago, CentralMA said:

I'm thinking I could be happy with the base RCS, 15k burners. Going down the rabbit hole of mumkin's links it looks like with a little bit of chicanery and a couple of hundred dollars I could save eight hundred and have higher output.

 

Still looking for input....I've not placed the order as yet.

 

Thanks all.

 

I don't own a blue star, but I have a GE with one larger burner, about 21k and it does come in useful for boiling water for pasta and wok cooking.     That said, I looked into various options like a 3/4 inch gas pipe and a professional range before coming to the conclusion I was being a bit crazy.  

 

The reason I am posting is to caution you about going around manufacturers guidelines to save a few bucks.   Part of what talked me out of the professional stove was looking into various fire codes and ordinances.  When you start to tinker with a range you at a minimum void any warranty, you may also void your home owners insurance if you have a fire.  I would proceed with caution.       

Edited by Dr. Teeth (log)
  • Like 1
gfweb

gfweb

Posted
Posted

Re boiling water for pasta.

You don't need heat two gallons for a few servings of noodles, a couple quarts is usually enough.

The traditional advice to use mass quantities of water is just wrong. Accomplishes nothing. The pasta doesn't know how much water is in the pot.

And the big pot wastes fuel, salt and water.

 

So if you need a wok burner only to boil water...

weinoo

weinoo

Posted
Posted

I started using much less water to boil pasta, often just 3 quarts for 1/2 - 3/4 lb. of pasta. If I'm making more pasta, I'll pull out the 6 or 8 quart soup pot for a pound or over.  I actually find the starchier water from using 3 quarts helps make a nicer sauce, though of course in a restaurant kitchen they'd add 1/2 pound of butter.

 

There are one or two brands of pasta I use, and in one or two shapes, where I find the 3 quarts to not be enough ; the pasta absorbs a lot of water. In that case, the extra five minutes I have while the water comes to a boil on my underpowered Wolf allows me a couple of slugs of wine, or a hit on the vape.

 

 

 

  • Like 2

Mitch Weinstein aka "weinoo"

Tasty Travails - My Blog

My eGullet FoodBog - A Tale of Two Boroughs

Was it you baby...or just a Brilliant Disguise?

SLB

SLB

Posted
Posted

I have had an RCS for about nine years, and I second the sense that the simmer is just too damn high.  

 

And I think the broiler is actually too hot for the top rack.  Or else the top rack is too close to broiler.  And the boiler pan which came with the range is heavy.  Heavy-plus-hot . . . sigh.

 

Also?  I am surprised at just how frequently the igniters need replacement. 

 

Some other part of the oven died on me after about four years of use, it cost a FORTUNE to repair. 

 

Finally, the housing gets very hot (they may have put more insulation in the later models, actually).  But I occasionally have small children over here, and while it's of course appropriate to *always* stay on guard with toddlers in the kitchen, I feel unusually nervous with this piece.  

 

It's possible that I got a lemon, one which didn't reveal itself until shortly after the warranty expired.  Certainly no one I know has had as many complaints about their Bluestar as me.  I love its simplicity of design as well as appearance.  When I got it, I just knew I would be taking it with me when I moved on from my current home. 

 

But I've come to think, I'm gonna be leaving it.   

  • Like 3
mumkin

mumkin

Posted
Posted

I appreciate the caution, Dr. Teeth. Using a product in an unapproved manner is a sure ticket to finding one's insurance coverage voided. It does seem that the RCS is otherwise identical to the RNB, so it's not inherently unsafe. But yeah, CentralMA should weigh the merits of $800 saved now vs. a claim inspector discovering the range wasn't to manufacturer's spec. 

 

SLB, from sifting through many reviews and forum posts, I gather that there've been several iterations of the oven door design in the last decade: different hinges, a bigger window, and insulation (or something) to keep the surface much cooler. And recently they've disabled the convection fan until the oven is at temp. Seems that broiler pans are only for RNB and Platinum units.

 

Those of you with a too-high BlueStar simmer, did you adjust the flame height and find that it just couldn't go low enough?

  • Like 1
gfweb

gfweb

Posted
Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, mumkin said:

I appreciate the caution, Dr. Teeth. Using a product in an unapproved manner is a sure ticket to finding one's insurance coverage voided. It does seem that the RCS is otherwise identical to the RNB, so it's not inherently unsafe. But yeah, CentralMA should weigh the merits of $800 saved now vs. a claim inspector discovering the range wasn't to manufacturer's spec. 

 

SLB, from sifting through many reviews and forum posts, I gather that there've been several iterations of the oven door design in the last decade: different hinges, a bigger window, and insulation (or something) to keep the surface much cooler. And recently they've disabled the convection fan until the oven is at temp. Seems that broiler pans are only for RNB and Platinum units.

 

Those of you with a too-high BlueStar simmer, did you adjust the flame height and find that it just couldn't go low enough?

Adjusting helps. I just redid it and it's much better. The original adjustment was done with a dodgy regulator on the propane tank...kept going out on low. Didnt think to redo it with the new regulator. Thanks for the thought!

Edited by gfweb (log)
  • Like 3
paulraphael

paulraphael

Posted
Posted

You don't need 22K in a home kitchen. I probably have 900 and it doesn't hold me back. But if I COULD have 22K? Of course I'd love it. Maybe not for an added $1000, but if I could upgrade down the road for a few hundred, yes please.

 

There are some advantages to big-ass BTUs. Boiling pasta water in less time comes to mind. Preheating a pan for searing anything in about a minute. 

 

You can also rethink your pans. If you have that kind of horsepower, you really don't need energy storage. So you can exclusively use lightweight, responsive stuff, like thin spun steel or all-clad, or lighter weight commercial aluminum. You'll never have to wait around for a pan to preheat, and everything will be responsive. 

 

There are downsides. People not used to the power might freak out, or burn themselves, or destroy your cookware. You'll set your side towels on fire. But I'd take my chances.

 

For what it's worth, I've never cooked on BlueStar, but it's almost certainly what I'd pick if I had the $$$. I don't see anything else that's as serious, with open burners, and no b.s..

  • Like 5

Notes from the underbelly

Barrytm

Barrytm

Posted
Posted

I have the RNB 30,  though I think when I was looking, the RCS was only offered with the sealed burner, or , I was just confused and thought that all RCS's were sealed, that is why I went for the RNB.  If the only difference is 1 higher powered burner, that would be hard to justify for me, since I tend to not even notice whether I am using the 15,000 or the 18,000 burners.  As to the simmer burner, on the RNB  ( and may be true for the RCS ) you can turn the grate a quarter turn, and it lifts it up slightly, so that you get a lower simmer.  

 

The manual says to not use the top rack for broiling, instead use the second rack and the broiler pan, that puts the food a little farther from the broiler element than on the top rack,  though I often just use a sheet pan on the top rack, and check it often and rotate.  The area of the broiler it is pretty small, so you definitely need to rotate the sheet pan, otherwise the items right under will brown more quickly than those not directly under the broiler.    I think you will be happy either way you go.  

SLB

SLB

Posted
Posted

My manual does not say that, @Barrytm (my model was going discontinued in 2011, so maybe yours is newer?), but in any case I'v been using the second rack.  Which  is actually a little far from the broiler.  But so far I've made it work. 

Barrytm

Barrytm

Posted
Posted

SLB,   what I found was that using a sheet pan on the second rack was a little too far, using the broiler pan,  which is bit of a pain to locate in the pantry, puts it up higher, though not as high as the top rack.  

SLB

SLB

Posted
Posted

That certainly explains the robustness of the Bluestar broiler-pan.   That thing is heavy, it annoys me.  

 

My bluestar experience annoys me generally.  I love its concept.  But mine has got some problem too much of the time. 

 

Also, someone dropped one of the grates and it broke, and BS won't replace just the grate, you have to buy the whole assembly. 

 

The broken grate of mine pieces together alright, which is how I roll.  And I live in a vibrant city where there is someone, not even a Brooklyn Hipster, who can make me a new one.  Pre-pandemic, anyway . . . .

 

I will say this:  that drip-tray concept is one-hundred-percent perfect.  I've never had that before.  I have had open-burners before, but you lifted the top of the stove on some kind of hinge, and proceeded to clean one-handed.   The tray rocks.  

  • Like 2
gfweb

gfweb

Posted
Posted
2 hours ago, SLB said:

I will say this:  that drip-tray concept is one-hundred-percent perfect.  I've never had that before.  I have had open-burners before, but you lifted the top of the stove on some kind of hinge, and proceeded to clean one-handed.   The tray rocks.  

 

Covering that drip tray with foil makes cleaning even easier.

  • Like 1
Barrytm

Barrytm

Posted
Posted

SLB,   a hipster may not be able to help you make a new grate, but you might check Craigslist  or other online list of services -  to find someone local who is good at welding.  The best would be someone who has experience brazing ( which is not welding ) and brazing is  better suited to repairing cast iron.  Welding can work too, but it requires a bit of skill .   Depending on the number of cracks, it could be fairly inexpensive repair.    

 

 

  Agree on the drip tray, that was the selling point for me.  

  • 3 weeks later...
CentralMA

CentralMA

Posted
Posted

Been a while.

 

Tripped the hammer. A new 30" RNB is on it's way. Two 22K, one 15K, one 9K burner. Full size sheet pan size oven. 

 

Way too much money, but I got some concessions. Saved about 10%.

 

Yay.

  • Like 5
CentralMA

CentralMA

Posted
Posted
On 5/1/2020 at 8:44 PM, paulraphael said:

You don't need 22K in a home kitchen. I probably have 900 and it doesn't hold me back. But if I COULD have 22K? Of course I'd love it. Maybe not for an added $1000, but if I could upgrade down the road for a few hundred, yes please.

 

There are some advantages to big-ass BTUs. Boiling pasta water in less time comes to mind. Preheating a pan for searing anything in about a minute. 

 

You can also rethink your pans. If you have that kind of horsepower, you really don't need energy storage. So you can exclusively use lightweight, responsive stuff, like thin spun steel or all-clad, or lighter weight commercial aluminum. You'll never have to wait around for a pan to preheat, and everything will be responsive. 

 

There are downsides. People not used to the power might freak out, or burn themselves, or destroy your cookware. You'll set your side towels on fire. But I'd take my chances.

 

For what it's worth, I've never cooked on BlueStar, but it's almost certainly what I'd pick if I had the $$$. I don't see anything else that's as serious, with open burners, and no b.s..

 

Gotta say, this was the reply that pushed me over the edge.

 

Do I really need it? 22K? Nah. Would I like it? Hell, yeah. Full size sheet pan? Do I need it? Nah. Would I like it? Hell, yes.

 

What pushed me over the edge to the RNB? There was a need for the government to throw money at us, my wife and I eventually got the check. I decided to push those $$$ to a local small business that sells BlueStars, something I've been coveting for some time. Paid for 1/2 the cost of the range. I win, and the small business wins. 

 

As for towels on fire, I've had fire extinguishers in my kitchen for years now. Have never had to use them. Damn it, bring it on!

 

Thank you Paul. Many thanks.

  • Like 2
gfweb

gfweb

Posted
Posted
On 5/29/2020 at 10:35 PM, CentralMA said:

Been a while.

 

Tripped the hammer. A new 30" RNB is on it's way. Two 22K, one 15K, one 9K burner. Full size sheet pan size oven. 

 

Way too much money, but I got some concessions. Saved about 10%.

 

Yay.

You will love it.  The price difference is amortized over the rest of your life. A buck a week.

 

Make sure the installer adjusts the simmer

 

Congratulations !

CentralMA

CentralMA

Posted
Posted

I'll be sure to see that the installer adjusts the simmer. I'll be he.

 

I'll be picking it up from the appliance dealer, transporting the range to the house, and overseeing the installation. Gas fitter will be there for the install, and hopefully the final city inspection will be scheduled at that time, signing off on it all.

 

I'm looking forward to it all. 

  • Like 1
CentralMA

CentralMA

Posted
Posted
10 minutes ago, gfweb said:

The price difference is amortized over the rest of your life. A buck a week.

 

A buck a week? You're saying I'm going to live for another 96 years?

 

I hope that's not true....

  • Haha 2
  • 1 month later...
CentralMA

CentralMA

Posted
Posted

Update:

 

Stove was ordered on May 29th, paid in full.

 

Received word today, Juy 14th, that the BlueStar mothership says it should ship from Pennsylvania this week.

 

Good news, I guess. Might not be able to pick it up for some time though, a wedding is in the way.

  • Like 3
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...