Commercial mayonnaise – likes, dislikes?

[JoNorvelleWalker]

I tried the Duke's and Hellman's test.  I prefer Hellman's.  This could be because Hellman's is what I'm used to, or because the jar of Duke's was past its prime.  The Duke's flavor tasted somewhat off.

 

[rotuts]

for completeness sake , Im adding Burman's the Aldi mayo :

 

https://www.prospre.io/ingredients/burmans-real-mayonnaise-51897

 

 

 

Ill add my Dukes vs Aldi ( Burman's )  when I open a fresh jar of each  at the same time.

 

that Dukes has to last me a long long long time if i like it , as its up to $ 5.99

 

B is probably 3.49 , just a guess 

Edited yesterday at 07:09 PM by rotuts (log)

[gfweb]

Dukes has twang.

I hate twang.

[rotuts]

@gfweb

 

Ive never tasted twang.

 

Ill be cautious when I try it .

 

of course , you welcome to alert me to other twangs youv'e tried that did not agree with you..

 

it would save me a lot of time and lucre.  

 

thanks

Edited 20 hours ago by rotuts (log)

[gfweb]

30 minutes ago, rotuts said:

@gfweb

 

Ive never tasted twang.

 

Ill be cautious when I try it .

 

of course , you welcome to alert me to other twangs youv'e tried that did not agree with you..

 

it would save me a lot of time and lucre.  

 

thanks

 

Dukes confesses twang on their lid so they must put it in there.  I consider it more a warning than a selling point and I'm grateful for the transparency.

 

 

[Shel_B]

It's been years since posting that TJ's was my favorite, and things have changed.  Best Foods has moved to the #1 spot, but not the squeeze bottle version. Just the plain ol' regular version. I've heard that there's a thicker version that a lot of delis and commercial establishments use, but I've not tried it yet. I'm unclear if it's available under the Best Foods lable, but it is under the Hellman's name.

 

Since my earlier posts, I've tried Kewpie, and ther's always a bottle (if you can call it that) in the fridge. My favorite use for it is for Japanese-style egg salad sandwiches, but it's used on other items as well.

[Smithy]

12 minutes ago, Shel_B said:

Best Foods has moved to the #1 spot, but not the squeeze bottle version. Just the plain ol' regular version.

 

That's an interesting distinction. The Hellman's I wrote about above came from a squeeze bottle rather than a jar. I'll have to look at the ingredient lists on both the jar and the bottle. Maybe there's a difference?

[Shel_B]

30 minutes ago, Smithy said:

 

That's an interesting distinction. The Hellman's I wrote about above came from a squeeze bottle rather than a jar. I'll have to look at the ingredient lists on both the jar and the bottle. Maybe there's a difference?

 

My experience was the same

Edited 13 hours ago by Shel_B (log)

[chromedome]

4 hours ago, Smithy said:

 

That's an interesting distinction. The Hellman's I wrote about above came from a squeeze bottle rather than a jar. I'll have to look at the ingredient lists on both the jar and the bottle. Maybe there's a difference?

Huh. 

In my own kitchen I can assure you there's no difference, because I buy the big jar and use it to refill my squeeze bottle.

[weinoo]

I miss mayo that used to come in glass jars.

[rotuts]

TJ's had a mayo years ago .  in a glass jar .

 

it was very very yolk-ey and delicious.

 

I wonder who made ir and what happened to it .