Jump to content
  • Welcome to the eG Forums, a service of the eGullet Society for Culinary Arts & Letters. The Society is a 501(c)3 not-for-profit organization dedicated to the advancement of the culinary arts. These advertising-free forums are provided free of charge through donations from Society members. Anyone may read the forums, but to post you must create a free account.

Edit History

Honkman

Honkman

19 minutes ago, scott123 said:

And, just to be clear, scientists have the power to redefine all regional specialties?  

It really shouldn't be a hard concept to grasp that the people of the region where a product was developed have the right to define it. 

You live in a town. Nathan lives in a town. Chris Young lives in a town.  If any of your science produces a better mousetrap, name your pizza style after your town. Enough with the appropriation.

 

It's not scientists or people of the region or Nathan who ultimate define what a product is called but ultimately whoever makes the dish. It is the same discussion as with "authentic" dishes - what you define as authentic might not be the same what I define as authentic and we are both right.  Where you are fundamentally wrong (even beyond just food) is " You're mistakingly assuming that there's multiple routes to the same destination" - yes, there are always multiple routes to the same destination outside of food, within food and also Neapolitan pizza. It's quite preposterous to believe there is only one way to make Neapolitan pizza and every other approach in the future can only lead to inferior results. 

Honkman

Honkman

3 minutes ago, scott123 said:

And, just to be clear, scientists have the power to redefine all regional specialties?  

It really shouldn't be a hard concept to grasp that the people of the region where a product was developed have the right to define it. 

You live in a town. Nathan lives in a town. Chris Young lives in a town.  If any of your science produces a better mousetrap, name your pizza style after your town. Enough with the appropriation.

 

It's not scientists or people of the region or Nathan who ultimate define what a product is called but ultimately whoever makes the dish. It is the same discussion as with "authentic" dishes - what you define as authentic might not be the same what I define as authentic and we are both right.  (And I don't believe in the value of Where you are fundamentally wrong (even beyond just food) is " You're mistakingly assuming that there's multiple routes to the same destination" - yes, there are always multiple routes to the same destination outside of food, within food and also Neapolitan pizza. It's quite preposterous to believe there is only one way to make Neapolitan pizza and every other approach in the future can only lead to inferior results. 

×
×
  • Create New...