Jump to content

gfweb

participating member
  • Posts

    11,780
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by gfweb

  1. Perhaps, but to be fair throughout the series no scores were given when chefs were asked to go.

    My reading of the score would be that all the ICs wanted Garces, and probably 2 of the judges. And Jeffery was probably just adding some drama before voting for Garces. He isn't stupid after all.

  2. I am not sure what I think of this. Gotta test it.

    But I suspect that there will be a wave of protest saying that the old way is the best....well because it just is.

    I recall the fairly recent NYT piece on boiling pasta in minimal water and, even worse, adding the pasta to the water when its cold. There were any number of replies on eG saying that this had to be a bad way to cook and that the poster would never ever do it themselves.

    Similar posts in response to a method of cooking french fries starting with cold oil. Heresy and blasphemy!

    Not that every new way is better, or that one should believe everything that is printed, but without innovation there is no progress.

  3. I've not been to the philly Delfriscos, but I have been to the ones in DFW and have always been pleased. A shame it isn't good up here.

    My two nominees for worst steakhouse are both in DE. Conley-Ward (tiny ill-cooked portions and lousy service) and Sullivan's, which is a chain, I believe. Solidly mediocre.

  4. there are so many ways that these sorts of study can be misleading. The soda could be an epiphenomenon... a factor that is linked but not causal. For example fat hypertensive people try to lose weight by drinking diet soda. Obesity ad hypertension are both causes of kidney damage and the diet cola just a marker for the real risk factor. Another issue is that there are many different sweeteners of varying structure and presumably potentially varying effects on the kidney. The study did not appear to differentiate. If all were of equal renal risk then that is strong inference that they finding is an epiphenomenon.

    I have plenty of examples of bogus statistical correlation eg rock music and oil production...banana imports and genital cancer etc etc

    I'd wait for confirmation.

  5. Bad over-reaction on the part of management and the cops. Bad judgment on the part of the patrons. Management was worse. It won't happen again.... they should be out of business soon unless they start a big PR campaign up there that includes all kinds of apologies and comps to all involved. College students love to get angry about stuff (and this isn't an election year) so that place is in big trouble.

  6. Mehta is cast as the vampirish villain; a role he is well-suited to and probably in some way reflective of reality. With the editing we really don't know whether the judges were completely impressed or not with his meal.

    So the last show is down to Garces vs Mehta. Good vs. evil.

    What drama.

×
×
  • Create New...