Highlawn Pavilion or Hilton Short Hills?

[rnfoodie]

Need to "impress" for a business dinner. Abut 7-10 people. Seems pricing is similar for both, approx. $ 130.00 p/p, meal, wine tax, tip etc. Actually more than I had planned to spend , but seems these are the best in area. Which would you choose? Other suggestions?

[Susan]

What about the Stage House Inn?

[Rosie]

If you have a clear night the Highlawn Pavilion has a gorgeous view of the NY City skyline. Also, the 9/11 Memorial is there. Haven't been to the Dining Room in a long time.

[Rachel Perlow]

The problem, IMO, with the Hilton Dining Room is that if you are dealing with out-of-towners they won't realize at first that you are taking them to one of the nicest places in NJ, but instead to a hotel restaurant, you know what I mean? If they are locals and know anything about the restaurant scene, it is an excellent choice. Also, what about The Manor?

[joi h.]

i agree with the problem of people unfamiliar with the dining room making the distinction between the dining room and other "hotel restaurants." however, we recently were there for our anniversary and had one of the best meals ever! top shelf for every aspect of dining. if you are looking to impress not so much with food but with a great view of nyc, go with the highlawn; only problem being that you have no idea if the weather will cooperate with your plans.

[Jason Perlow]

never been but I heard Serenade is really nice. I'd also investigate Pierre's.

[Rail Paul]

"need to impress" them with what?

If you're looking for food, any of the suggestions will prob be impressive. If you're looking for the "view", go with the Highlawn. Be aware, however, that the Highlawn's tables for 5+ are set back from the windows. With 10 people, they may offer you two tables.

For 10 people, Serenade may give your group the fireplace room, depending on how booked they are. Their tasting menu with wine selection run about $110, IIRC

[ngatti]

"need to impress" them with what?

If you're looking for food, any of the suggestions will prob be impressive. If you're looking for the "view", go with the Highlawn.  Be aware, however, that the Highlawn's tables for 5+ are set back from the windows. With 10 people, they may offer you two tables.

For 10 people, Serenade may give your group the fireplace room, depending on how booked they are. Their tasting menu with wine selection run about $110, IIRC

Yes, I would agree. If you're looking to impress with a culinary experience, skip Highlawn. I've not been to Stagehouse, but it gets a lot of good press here on this board. It's on my list.

Nick

[Rosie]

Yes, Serenade would be a very good choice also. Another option is Scalini Fedeli.

[RockADS21]

I dont know if location matters to you as you initially mentioned places that are approx. 20-30 minutes from each other...but as other choices I would concur with Stage House, Scalini Fedeli and Serenade and I would also add The Bernards Inn...all very impressive places with top notch cuisine...Enjoy!