NY News: El Maguey Y La Tuna

[NY News Team]

There's a rumor that there's no such thing as a good Mexican restaurant in New York. I would never know the difference, having never been south of the Texas border. El Maguey is one of those little unassuming places that claims to be as close to authentic Mexican as possible, which may or may not be true, but with its red lights and colorful table cloths the place definitely has charm. As for the food, the mole over pork ordered by my friends were proclaimed as "out of this world" and my shrimp fajita was sizzling and tasty. Also, came highly recommended from friends were the spicy nacho with chorizo and the shrimp cocktails, which went well with the nice cold negra modelo. El Maguey Y La Tuna may not be genuine Mexican, but it's still pretty damn good.--Y. Yang

El Maguey Y La Tuna

321 East Houston Street

Telephone: (212)473-3744

[Pan]

So you liked it, Ya-Roo? What cross-streets is it nearest to? I'd like to walk past and check out the menu.

[Bond Girl]

Ir's on Houston between B and C. It's a pretty cool place.

[jeunefilleparis]

i still think that mexicana mama on hudson street has the best burritos ever, my friend, who happens to be mexican says that they are pretty damn good too:)

[Pan]

Best burritos ever? Better than La Super-Rica in Santa Barbara? I doubt it.

[LESider]

I had lunch there a week ago and it was just ok. I had a beef burrito. and my fiance had an avocado salad. I live only a few blocks away so I was crossing my fingers that it would be a worthy stop. I may try it again, but I have to say if they can't do a simple beef burrito... Why can't somebody open up a good taqueria in this town? damn.

I was just in California this weekend and had a fish taco that was excellent. Not even a tacqueria but some random cafe in Mendocino. the flavors are fresh and bright. The salsa excellent pico de gallo, the beans : black and tasty, the rice fine. Guacamole. hit the spot. and fresh corn tortilla's.

then search continue's

[jeunefilleparis]

Best burritos ever? Better than La Super-Rica in Santa Barbara? I doubt it. 

ok ok, i meant best burritos in NYC, PAN:)

[Pan]

I had lunch there a week ago and it was just ok.

Is "there" El Maguey Y La Tuna or Mexicana Mama?