Forget about the subjectivity of the reviewer. He's just terribly inconsistent with ratings. Didn't you think after reading the actual review of Otto that it would be awarded no more than one star? Compare the text with Grimes' review of Branzini of a few weeks ago. The review for Branzini seemed quite a bit better than Otto's yet Branzini only received one star. Same price points, level of service, atmosphere, etc. so you can compare apples with apples.