• Welcome to the eG Forums, a service of the eGullet Society for Culinary Arts & Letters. The Society is a 501(c)3 not-for-profit organization dedicated to the advancement of the culinary arts. These advertising-free forums are provided free of charge through donations from Society members. Anyone may read the forums, but to post you must create an account.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

"Formulas for Flavour" – John Campbell

10 posts in this topic

I am very curious about this title, but my local libraries do not have it and I always hate buying cookbooks I don't end up using.

Can anyone tell me whether or not they like this cookbook and how many dessert/pastry/bread recipes it has?


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

It's kind of a cross between The Cook's Book and David Everett-Matthias's Essence, if that's any help. :smile:

Everyone I've ever recommended it to has agreed it's one of the best cookbook's around. The recipes are all really strong, maybe not as complex as Thomas Keller's, but what really makes it worth owning is the way it shows the (experienced) home cook how to replicate restaurant-level food - Campbell has just been given a 2nd Michelin star - without killing themselves with stress.

On the surface the book just shows how to recreate a bunch of starters, mains and desserts, with little reference info for stuff like bread or pastry, but by including step-by-step instructions and photos for each stage of every dish, along with useful explanations about which elements can be prepared in advance, it actually imparts loads of great practical knowledge.

restaurant, private catering, consultancy
feast for the senses / blog

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Good book. Relatively complex recipes, but a lot of hard science and explanation behind it and step by step pictures. Gives you a lot of comfort the recipes will actually WORK despite the complexity.

Not massively long but longer than the Champ Sauv book (whos brevity was its only weakness). Normal balance of starter/main/pudding recipes

Def worth getting.

Better than the restaurant, in my experience


More Cookbooks than Sense - my new Cookbook blog!

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Its OK, but now a little dated and nothing that is not done elsewhere.

Lots of pictures, and I use the roast onion icecream recipe.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

The weekend before last, as a minor celebration of Chef Campbell’s promotion to the 2-star elite, I had a small dinner party based exclusively on some the of ‘Formulas for Flavour’ book.

The menu was:-

Roast scallop with artichoke barigoule

Turbot, braised ox tail, parsley & lemon oil

Citrus soufflé, hot chocolate ice cream

First thing to say was – the recipes look far less impressive than the taste they deliver. The flavours build on each other to create an impressive and substantial result.

Initially the quantities seemed over generous, but they worked out fine.

The recipes are generally detailed but, despite all the notes, and ‘do this now’ instructions, they are a bit disorganised and need much more careful planning if you are working on your own. I didn’t have any of the basic, starting materials and, from start to finish, it took 11 hours preparation spread across 2 days.

The second thing to be aware of is the cost of ingredients. I don’t have access to a) kitchen wholesalers or b) US food prices which can be significantly below London costs. Total ingredient cost for the menu was around US$175 for four persons. With the very large number of top-quality ingredients, the costs add up quickly. Unlike Essence which uses a lot of obscure herbs, most of the ingredients are easily found (at least in London).

I would absolutely recommend this book, but beware the troublesome journey to arrive at 2-star nirvana. The book is not expensive compared with some other personality chefs, but the binding is not of the best quality.

PS There are 10 starters, 10 mains and 10 desserts, plus a range of stocks and sauces (6 bread types).

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

can you tell me what some of the desserts are? I have no idea other than the souffle, and a peach tart with black pepper ice cream.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Dessert recipes:

Roast Plums, Honey and Yogurt Ice Cream

Chocolate and Griottine Clafoutis

Bitter Chocolate Tart, Parsnip Ice Cream

White Chocolate Mousse, Raspberry Milkshake

Citrus Soufflé, Hot Chocolate Ice Cream

Panna Cotta with Raspberries

‘Rhubarb and Custard’

‘Strawberry Shortcake’, Balsamic Ice Cream

Tarte Fine of Peach, Pepper Ice Cream

Tatin of Pear with Roquefort and Pickled Walnut Ice Cream

I have only tried the soufflé recipe from the dessert section and, in case you wonder, the ‘Hot Chocolate’ is not hot, it’s drinking chocolate. It was relatively simple to do. The soufflé rose as smoothly and evenly as could be hoped for, only I probably overcooked it by a couple of minutes as the texture was just very slightly rubbery on top. The dish had a great taste and looked great on the plate. The hot chocolate ice cream is really unforgettable (in a good way).

As with all the recipes in the book, most of these have multiple ingredients and are restaurant dishes. The photos are helpful both in illustrating the techniques and the final presentation.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Great buy! And not as big of an investment as other books out there. Buy it, you wont be disapointed!

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Similar Content

    • By Lisa Shock
      The team over at Modernist Cuisine announced today that their next project will be an in-depth exploration of bread. I personally am very excited about this, I had been hoping their next project would be in the baking and pastry realm. Additionally, Francisco Migoya will be head chef and Peter Reinhart will assignments editor for this project which is expected to be a multi-volume affair.
    • By Chris Hennes
      While not a new cookbook by any means, I haven't really had time to dig into this one until now. We've previously discussed the recipes in Jerusalem: A Cookbook, but not much has been said about Plenty. So, here goes...
      Chickpea saute with Greek yogurt (p. 211)

      This was a great way to kick off my time with this book. The flavors were outstanding, particularly the use of the caraway seeds and lemon juice. I used freshly-cooked Rancho Gordo chickpeas, which of course helps! The recipe was not totally trivial, but considering the flavors developed, if you don't count the time to cook the chickpeas it came together very quickly. I highly recommend this dish.
    • By Bickery
      Hey Everyone! I'm kinda new to all this, so excuse any violation of mores.
      Searching google for anything on Mr. Steingarten on the web led me to
      this forum. It appears te me that most of you are food professionals or
      nearly that, while i'm just a 21-yr old student who likes to cook.

      I own both Jeffries books, and i've started putting together a list of
      all the books he sort of recommends in his writing. Thus came an idea
      for this forum, wouldn't it be fun to concoct a list of say 50
      cookbooks from the world over? I everybody, and hopefully mr
      Steingarten along with them, would contribute his or hers favourote
      books, this could be very interesting.

      Due to my limited library on the subject (most cookbooks i've read are
      mom's) i shall begin by contributing my current favourite.

      I shall put it in last place, because i'm sure a lot of you will have
      thing to say on the subject.


      50. La cucina essentiale - Stefano Cavallini

      I hope a lot of suggestions will follow!

      Yours Truly,


      (Host's Note: Thanks to eG member marmish, who has compiled a list of everything mentioned as of the end of July 2009: it can be found here. -CH)
    • By liuzhou
      I'm hearing rumours of a new book from Fuchsia Dunlop, this time on Zhejiang cuisine from the east of China around Hangzhou and Ningbo, south of Shanghai. No date or title - or confirmation yet.
    • By Droo
      I'm making the citron cream recipe in Migoya's Elements of Desserts (p318/9?).
      It says to cook the anglaise to 85 degrees, place on an ice bath then whip the anglaise. I've done that but it doesn't seem to whip (let alone to a medium peak).
      This is a new technique I've not tried before so I'm at a loss. Anyone have any ideas?
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.