Jump to content
  • Welcome to the eG Forums, a service of the eGullet Society for Culinary Arts & Letters. The Society is a 501(c)3 not-for-profit organization dedicated to the advancement of the culinary arts. These advertising-free forums are provided free of charge through donations from Society members. Anyone may read the forums, but to post you must create a free account.

Edit History

liuzhou

liuzhou

If I tell you that the third character in the name S: 沙丁鱼; T: 沙丁魚 (shā dīng yú), or means fish, then you might be able to guess which fish I’m talking about from the pronunciation of the two preceding characters - 沙丁 (shā dīng). Think phonetically.

 

OK. It means ‘sardine’, for which Chinese has adopted this as a loanword from the English using the characters they consider closest in Chinese phonology.

 

But that doesn’t help much; sardine isn’t a species of fish as such, but a group of different species in the herring family, Clupeidae. What you think of as sardines may be a very different species from what I think. For me, sardines are Sardina or Clupea pilchardus, the European sardine found in the waters illustrated in the map below.

 

58ee3d6d55fbb2fb43161f45e41f37a4462309f77614.thumb.jpg.7c5d3c02913e4b9650ca353cb4bbe5f9.jpg

Public Domain Map

 

My main, usually reliable Chinese-English dictionary claims that 沙丁鱼 means Clupea pilchardus. However, the size and shape of these is different and it’s unlikely that China would be importing sardines from Europe when the waters off the coast of southern China is home to Sardina hualiensis, a Pacific sardine also known as Taiwan sardinella.

 

pic_Fis-23772.jpg.5700f58c00df075e4854456859fad728.jpg Distribution of Sardina hualiensis, Taiwan sardinella.  AquaMaps (2019, October). Computer generated distribution maps for Sardinella hualiensis (Taiwan sardinella), with modelled year 2050 native range map based on IPCC RCP8.5 emissions scenario. Retrieved from https://www.aquamaps.org.

 

So, I’m betting these are those or another of the Pacific varieties such as S. brachysoma. Their descriptions more closely fit.

 

sardines3.thumb.jpg.c873f5ebbfad1eaf4913156800520b01.jpg

Chinese sardines

 

Interestingly, I’ve never encountered China processed canned sardines. Although canned sardines are available in some stores, they are never Chinese. We get ‘555’ brand from the Philippines

 

555Sardines.thumb.jpg.f64e1dd1ed22890d213068163ad0df5b.jpg

 

and ‘Smiling Fish’ brand from Thailand.

 

sardines2.thumb.jpg.e91bcfbf81a6fac4d173abfcf6ff32a9.jpg

 

Few supermarkets carry canned sardines; almost unthinkable in the west.

 

I buy Portuguese canned sardines in boxes of 20 cans from an expensive import store.

 

portuguesesardines2.thumb.jpg.3cd304c648541408c00c30868455ed3f.jpg

 

Happiness is sardines on toast.

 

sardinesontoast2.thumb.jpg.96031e714ef1ba8078e588b0a1ba3ed5.jpg

 

 

liuzhou

liuzhou

If I tell you that the third character in the name S: 沙丁鱼; T: 沙丁魚 (shā dīng yú), or means fish, then you might be able to guess which fish I’m talking about from the pronunciation of the two preceding characters - 沙丁 (shā dīng). Think phonetically.

 

OK. It means ‘sardine’, for which Chinese has adopted this as a loanword from the English using the characters they consider closest in Chinese phonology.

 

But that doesn’t help much; sardine isn’t a species of fish as such, but a group of different species in the herring family, Clupeidae. What you think of as sardines may be a very different species from what I think. For me, sardines are Sardina or Clupea pilchardus, the European sardine found in the waters illustrated in the map below.

 

58ee3d6d55fbb2fb43161f45e41f37a4462309f77614.thumb.jpg.7c5d3c02913e4b9650ca353cb4bbe5f9.jpg

Public Domain Map

 

My main, usually reliable Chinese-English dictionary claims that 沙丁鱼 means Clupea pilchardus. However, the size and shape of these is different and it’s unlikely that China would be importing sardines from Europe when the waters off the coast of southern China is home to Sardina hualiensis, a Pacific sardine also known as Taiwan sardinella.

 

pic_Fis-23772.jpg.5700f58c00df075e4854456859fad728.jpg Distribution of Sardina hualiensis, Taiwan sardinella.  AquaMaps (2019, October). Computer generated distribution maps for Sardinella hualiensis (Taiwan sardinella), with modelled year 2050 native range map based on IPCC RCP8.5 emissions scenario. Retrieved from https://www.aquamaps.org.

 

So, I’m betting these are those or another of the Pacific varieties such as S. brachysoma. Their descriptions more closely fit.

 

sardines3.thumb.jpg.c873f5ebbfad1eaf4913156800520b01.jpg

Chinese sardines

 

Interestingly, I’ve never encountered China processed canned sardines. Although canned sardines are available in some stores, they are never Chinese. We get ‘555’ brand from the Philippines

 

555Sardines.thumb.jpg.f64e1dd1ed22890d213068163ad0df5b.jpg

 

and ‘Smiling Fish’ brand from Thailand.

 

sardines2.thumb.jpg.e91bcfbf81a6fac4d173abfcf6ff32a9.jpg

 

Neither are very good. We occasionally see Russian sardines, too.

 

RussianSardines1.thumb.jpg.5d2008fede0b99c127012d60907e2d8d.jpg

 

Few supermarkets carry canned sardines; almost unthinkable in the west.

 

I buy Portuguese canned sardines in boxes of 20 cans from an expensive import store.

 

portuguesesardines2.thumb.jpg.3cd304c648541408c00c30868455ed3f.jpg

 

Happiness is sardines on toast.

 

sardinesontoast2.thumb.jpg.96031e714ef1ba8078e588b0a1ba3ed5.jpg

 

 

 

 

liuzhou

liuzhou

If I tell you that the third character in the name S: 沙丁鱼; T: 沙丁魚 (shā dīng yú), or means fish, then you might be able to guess which fish I’m talking about from the pronunciation of the two preceding characters - 沙丁 (shā dīng). Think phonetically.

 

OK. It means ‘sardine’, for which Chinese has adopted this as a loanword from the English using the characters they consider closest in Chinese phonology.

 

But that doesn’t help much; sardine isn’t a species of fish as such, but a group of different species in the herring family, Clupeidae. What you think of as sardines may be a very different species from what I think. For me, sardines are Sardina or Clupea pilchardus, the European sardine found in the waters illustrated in the map below.

 

58ee3d6d55fbb2fb43161f45e41f37a4462309f77614.thumb.jpg.7c5d3c02913e4b9650ca353cb4bbe5f9.jpg

Public Domain Map

 

My main, usually reliable Chinese-English dictionary claims that 沙丁鱼 means Clupea pilchardus. However, the size and shape of these is different and it’s unlikely that China would be importing sardines from Europe when the waters off the coast of southern China is home to Sardina hualiensis, a Pacific sardine also known as Taiwan sardinella.

 

pic_Fis-23772.jpg.5700f58c00df075e4854456859fad728.jpg Distribution of Sardina hualiensis, Taiwan sardinella.  AquaMaps (2019, October). Computer generated distribution maps for Sardinella hualiensis (Taiwan sardinella), with modelled year 2050 native range map based on IPCC RCP8.5 emissions scenario. Retrieved from https://www.aquamaps.org.

 

So, I’m betting these are those or another of the Pacific varieties such as S. brachysoma. Their descriptions more closely fit.

 

sardines3.thumb.jpg.c873f5ebbfad1eaf4913156800520b01.jpg

Chinese sardines

 

Interestingly, I’ve never encountered China processed canned sardines. Although canned sardines are available in some stores, they are never Chinese. We get ‘555’ brand from the Philippines

 

555Sardines.thumb.jpg.f64e1dd1ed22890d213068163ad0df5b.jpg

 

and ‘Smiling Fish’ brand from Thailand.

 

sardines2.thumb.jpg.e91bcfbf81a6fac4d173abfcf6ff32a9.jpg

 

Neither are very good. We occasionally see Russian sardines, too.

 

RussianSardines1.thumb.jpg.5d2008fede0b99c127012d60907e2d8d.jpg

 

Few supermarkets carry canned sardines; almost unthinkable in the west.

 

I buy Portuguese canned sardines in boxes of 20 cans from an expensive import store.

 

portuguesesardines2.thumb.jpg.3cd304c648541408c00c30868455ed3f.jpg

 

Happiness is sardines on toast.

 

sardinesontoast2.thumb.jpg.96031e714ef1ba8078e588b0a1ba3ed5.jpg

 

 

Chinese sardines.jpg

Sardines in Tomato Sauce.jpg

×
×
  • Create New...