I tried one at their location in Williamsburg, Brooklyn a few years ago.
I think it was priced at $7 or $9 or something
and it tasted like a good pie - like one you would make at home using one of Rose Berenbaum's recipes in Baking Bible
but I think it was the first time I tasted normal store pie that tasted close to homemade (but less fresh)
if you don't cook or bake at home this pie will be like a new revelation or something bc all you've eaten are factory pies that taste like poop
but if you cook at home, then it's nothing special and just like what you make at home