Jump to content
  • Welcome to the eG Forums, a service of the eGullet Society for Culinary Arts & Letters. The Society is a 501(c)3 not-for-profit organization dedicated to the advancement of the culinary arts. These advertising-free forums are provided free of charge through donations from Society members. Anyone may read the forums, but to post you must create a free account.

Edit History

boilsover

boilsover

24 minutes ago, Kim Shook said:

Another question has occurred to me.  I started cooking with my grandmother's cast aluminum many years ago.  Certainly before I knew about any problem with acidic foods and aluminum.  I just realized that I routinely cook spaghetti sauce, vegetable soup with tomatoes and chili in this pot.  Am I slowly killing myself and my family????  

 

LOL, no, of course not.  IMO, there isn't a health concern, no matter what you cook or or how long.  The concerns are taste and color, and I don't even credit those very much.  Can 80% of restaurants worldwide be wrong?

 

Let's take a peek down the rabbithole, shall we?  Aluminum has a semi-unique property whereby it (and its alloys used in bare cookware) doesn't stay bare.  It oxidizes or "passivates" very quickly in the presence of oxygen.  How quickly?  About the time it takes for you to wash, dry and put away your pan.  What you're actually cooking on is  aluminum oxide, which is harder and less reactive than pure aluminum.  You can think of aluminum pans as being self-healing.  That's all hard anodizing is, BTW, except that HA creates a much thicker oxide layer.  Aluminum's astonishingly fast oxidation is the reason why there is virtually no metallic aluminum to be found in nature, despite the fact that it's the third most common element on Earth.   

boilsover

boilsover

7 minutes ago, Kim Shook said:

Another question has occurred to me.  I started cooking with my grandmother's cast aluminum many years ago.  Certainly before I knew about any problem with acidic foods and aluminum.  I just realized that I routinely cook spaghetti sauce, vegetable soup with tomatoes and chili in this pot.  Am I slowly killing myself and my family????  

 

LOL, no, of course not.  IMO, there isn't a health concern, no matter what you cook or or how long.  The concerns are taste and color, and I don't even credit those very much.  Can 80% of restaurants worldwide be wrong?

 

Let's take a peek down the rabbithole, shall we?  Aluminum has a semi-unique property whereby it (and its alloys used in bare cookware) doesn't stay bare.  It oxidizes or "passivates" very quickly in the presence of oxygen.  How quickly?  About the time it takes for you to wash, dry and put away your pan.  What you're actually cooking on is  aluminum oxide, which is harder and less reactive than pure aluminum.  You can think of aluminum pans as being self-healing.  That's all hard anodizing is, BTW, except that HA creates a much thicker oxide layer.  Aluminum's astonishingly fast oxidation is the reason why there is virtually no metallic aluminum in nature, despite the fact that it's the third most common element on Earth.   

×
×
  • Create New...