i tried this place (Hunan Cottage) for lunch not too long ago on the strength of the comments on this thread. there weren't many people there, and we were treated just as anyone else. we asked for the chinese menu as soon as we were seated, and it came out quickly. the soup dumplings were OK, but didn't compare to China 46, which is simply the benchmark. the tripe and tongue was OK. didn't have the peppercorn kick of China 46. a few other dishes were OK, although one of the dishes (i think it was pepper and salt squid), came served over some gratuitous tomato slices. that just detracted from the dish, and i could have done without the lame tomatoes. if i lived in that area, i would certainly consider this place to be a great find. but, i live much closer to C46, and C46 is just the effing bomb. in fact, i was at C46 last night with a group of friends, some of whom had never been, and they were just blown away and completely thrilled. Cecil brought some kindey out for us to snack on at the beginning of the meal. it was incredible. slightly sweet, with a nice spicy sauce. a really good dish.