This is the one that Won the CI tests. They like the shorter handle which keeps it balanced on the pan as well as the fine mesh that lets out steam but keeps back the blobs of moisture.
i happen to have the All Clad splatter screen which is fine but expensive, it's best feature is it's handle.
I have to admit that I've not used it much because I don't like to fry spattery foods due to the grease and fumes it leaves in my kitchen. When the weather's mild I do that stuff on my deck on an induction burner or deep fryer.