The recent thread about the Wine Spectator list and the new post by Craig Camp about the San Francisco Chronicle list have made me curious as to why there is such distate for wine lists and ratings. As a novice wine drinker I have little to no idea of where to start in selecting wines aside from sources like this and what I read here on eGullet. I want to do more than say - "Oh that's a pretty looking bottle, and its not too cheap or too expensive - let's go with that one." So in looking at these lists, along with the descriptions that accompany them, wouldn't that give me some idea of places to start? Obviously, the more you learn about wine the more you can make your own decisions, but couldn't these be helpful for me and my fellow beginners? Or is there something else I should be looking for?