Muddle one orange slice, one maraschino cherry, one teaspoon of super-fine sugar, a splash of bitters, and a splash of bourbon in the bottom of a highball glass until juicy. Fill the glass with crushed ice. Add two parts bourbon to one part water and stir. never, ever, use soda water. garnish with half orange slice. Preferred bourbons for Old Fashioneds: Maker's Mark Old Forester Booker's Knob Creek Baker's Woodford Reserve (pssst. its Old Forester too! just cost more)