OOOps, Sorry about that (new here...) Just my 2c. I think that BBQ as we generally know it was born in the southern US (I don't want to spark a debate as to what the Arawaks were doing or cavemen for that matter...or even grilling vs BBQ....I think you know what I mean). As such, I think, they developed good Q in the south and it became a benchmark. And as everyone developed their own regional techniques and tastes, they themselves became 'standards', such as Carolina, Memphis, Texas, Kansas City, etc. Everyone wants to emulate the 'best' and thats why joints in the rest of the world advertise "Memphis Style" or "Kansas City BBQ" . As for fuel, nobody was importing Brazilian hardwood charcoal. They simply used what was local, be it hickory, oak, mesquite. As their wood was accepted, they probably shrugged and just turned their nose to other woods. Why do north eastern joints use maple? Not because it offers that perfect nuance, or flavor, but because its nearby, easy to get, and cheap. Ask locally for charcoal and the first thing a supplier will probably offer is the feuille d'erable 100% hardwood lump charcoal from Ste Christine/Cte Portneuf (brown bag, red and blue print, red maple leaf). (Queue de Cheval uses it, Chalet BBQ uses it, etc). There are many techniques with smoking, some heavy, some light. I would like to think it depends on the application and the preference of the pit master. Can some stuff be oversmoked? Yessir. In the same breath, I'd say some stuff can be undersmoked. I think "embalmed with creosote" is a bit extreme. As for the health aspect, apparently any amount of smoke carries carcinogens (a risk I'm more than willing to take HAHA). OK, that said, I don't think you can properly compare Bo Finger and Mesquite. I wholeheartedly agree with wattacetti here (and on many other points) that Bo Finger is trying to be a BBQ pit and Mesquite is a restaurant selling BBQ. Both have a lot of potential and both fall short. Does this mean they're failing? Certainly not, as they are doing a brisk business (Bo Finger is apparently opening soon on the West Island). I was just hoping for BETTER Q. Mesquite, to me, was so lack luster that I simply lost interest. Bo Finger's opening had me jacked up, but my first visit was disappointing, as most everything was way too dry. OK it was their first week, so I tried again 3 weeks ago. Samething. I'm not that critical on their sides...they are after all only sides. What should be shining is the ribs, brisket, and sandwiches. But to my tastes, too dry. I only hope they can resolve this.