I feel a little timid asking you veterans, but I have a pressing question. I'm making my first starter ever -- I've only baked straight doughs before. My starter has been progressing nicely, doubling within a few hours when fed. But I read somewhere in this thread that it shouldn't smell "bad". Now, the starter doesn't smell awful, but it's a pretty sour smell, far more sour than yeasty. Not "spoiled" bad, like spoiled milk or rotting food, but definitely strong and sour. And I wouldn't want to be around it all the time. If it helps, I've been following the instructions in Joy (what I had handy when I managed to convince my girlfriend to do this). If my terminology is correct, it consists of 50% hydration feedings of a needed 50% hydration dough every 12 hours for 2 days, a 24 hour break (a sanity check -- is it bubbling when left alone?), followed by the same 12 hour 50% hydration schedule. So: is my sourdough spoiled? Is it a danger to bake with? If the only risk is a bad tasting bread, I'm willing to take that. If there's a risk of botulism toxin...not so much. Second question. We started the Joy plan on Monday Sunday, so we now have what should be a viable starter. It certainly looks spongy a few hours after feeding, so that's a good sign (I think). What we don't have are baguette pans or shaping baskets. Is oiled saran wrap in a bowl okay, or is that too much? Joy says we can just leave them dome side up and we'll only lose a little height. Any shaping tips for a complete novice?