Upper West Side Sushi

[Fat Guy]

What's currently the best? Is it just Gari end of discussion?

[Sethro]

Gari UWS is basically the menu from Gary UES 10 years ago, executed with way less care. Also, its incredulously expensive for how un-special it is. I guess decor and service-wise it might be the most impressive in the neighborhood, but the food is average.

Matsu on Columbus and 83rd is the best hole-in-the-wall sushi joint on the UWS. Very reasonable prices (even for a hole-in-the-wall), neatly assembled sushi and properly seasoned rice at the appropriate temperature. Definitely not a foodie experience, but solid and satisfying on every visit. It is my go-to.

Another option is Momoya, which is chain-y but good. Some serviceable Nobu-stolen dishes on the menu as well, so I guess it is kind of trendy. Its between Matsu and Gari price-wise, with a modern, clean atmosphere.

Everywhere else on the UWS that I've tried is either completely inedible or insanely expensive.

Edited February 3, 2011 by Sethro (log)

[LPShanet]

What's currently the best? Is it just Gari end of discussion?

I think it depends how far down you're still willing to call UWS. The hidden west side gem, in my opinion used to be Shimizu on West 51st. I know that's more midtown, but it would be worth going down a few extra blocks. Good traditional sushi. Not quite the level of the top places, but light years ahead of the middle level.

[Fat Guy]

I went there once and thought it was quite good, but no way are you going to get me to define it as Upper West Side!