Fresh tomato basil soup is one of the best things on earth. Besides, they're garden tomatoes, not holy relics. The perfect use for them is to satisfy whatever fresh tomato craving the recipient has. Your friend could do a LOT worse than tomato soup. Let me explain further, of course I wouldn't have minded if it was a soup or any other fresh tomato recipe but it wasn't it was a cooked ragu and they were added as a filler together with meat, sofrito, tinned tomatos and puree and I didn't feel it was the best use of them. The ragu was perfectly fine but it wasn't really enhanced by their addition because they weren't that suitable for cooking. If my friend said he'd enjoyed them as pane e pomodoro, tomato salad or even a sandwich that would have been more pleasing to me, that's just how I felt about it at the time. Was I a little too precious about them? Certainly, but that's because the summers here in the UK last about 3 weeks and seem to start and end in March.