Ate there again tonight for my 30th birthday. 1st course: Cod Threads, Pistachio Yogurt Asparagus The cod was very dry and chewy, like munching on flakes straight out of the bag, but without the strong salty flavor. It and the yogurt were actually both quite devoid of flavor. The asparagus was somewhere short of crisp, and slightly slimy. Oddly, although WD-50 is my favorite restaurant bar-none, I've rarely had a first course that worked for me there. 2nd Course: Carrot Coconut Sunny-Side-Up I thought this would have made a much better opener, being "breakfast" and such. The carrot flavor in particular really popped, aided by the perfect amount of black pepper, with just a mild sweetness. The coconut "white" actually tasted stronger of green cardamom than coconut, but thats fine with me. 3rd Course: Foie Gras, Candied olives, Pea Soil, Beet Juice For my money, no restaurant in New York does a better job with foie terrine than WD. I thought I'd never like a foie dish more than last year's offering with the nori caramel, but this was even better. The terrine itself was a perfect soft cream, with perfect textural balance from the pea soil and perfect sweetness from the beet. The dish would have been a 10 out of 10 even without the candied olives, which put the dish out of the realm of human comprehension and somewhere into the kingdom of etherea. I asked if I could have a bag of candied olives to go, and I was not kidding. Those things are AWESOME. The plate was stunning too, colorful and clean, with a great use of negative space. 4th Course: Shrimp Cous Cous, Dehydrated Papaya, Avocado Puree We opted away from the shrimp canneloni, having already sampled it twice in the past. This was basically a re-working of last years scallop cous-cous. I enjoyed this alot more though, mosty because the cous cous hit the table hot, and tasted like it had the help of some beef or bacon fat. The papaya was ok, but the avocado was completely lost. Decent dish, but nothing spectacular. 5th Course: Hangar Tartare, Bernaise Ice Cream, Asian Pear We also opted away from the tongue standard, having already sampled it twice as well. This dish was another stand-out. The meat was rich and perfectly seasoned, and the bernaise ice cream was as good tasting as it is cool sounding. What really did the trick for me was the healthy dose of clove and rice vinegar (I think) which dressed the pear. I loved everything about it. 6th Course: Langostine, Celery Root Fry, Bannana Mustard Probably the best cooked piece of langostine I've ever had; absolutely butter in the mouth. Everything else on the plate was forgetable to me, but man was that a well cooked crustacean. 7th Course: Corned Duck, Chinese Vinegar Reduction, [something I can't remember] The duck didn't really taste corned. Also it's skin wasn't crisp, and it was a little under-seasoned. The squid ink and vinegar reduction could have been a little more assertive. It wasn't a bad dish, just nothing I would order twice. Intermezzo: Tangerine Sorbet, basil, olive oil I liked this alot, although it was clearly a granite and not a sorbet at all. The citrus and olive oil worked great together, but I wish there was more basil. You really can't have too much basil. 1st Dessert Course: Coconut Cream Chese Sorbet, Carrot Foam, Carrot Cake Crumbs Loved the hell out of this! This was basically last year's Grapefruit-in-Grapefruit updated, but even better (which is saying alot). So smooth and so bright, the perfect dessert. 2nd Dessert Course: Manchego Cheesecake, Pineapple Foam, Bosc Pear After all the hype on Eg, I was actually a little let down. It was a very good cheesecake, but nothing new or unique. The pineapple foam was great and stood up on the plate like a champ for about 5 minutes, and played well with the cheese. The pear was pretty unnecesary and there was a manchego tuille that I thought was way too savory for a dessert course, and actually pretty nasty. Still, it was very good overall. 3rd Dessert Course: Kumquat Confit, Carob Ice Cream, Soy Caramel, Thyme Syrup This was my favorite dish of the night; everything on the plate worked in complete harmony. The kumquats were so juicy and tender, yet still pleasingly bitter. The carob ice cream was so earthy and rich. The soy caramel carried a perfect salinity to it that really tied the dish together. I could probably rate this as one of the best desserts I've ever had. I would have liked a bit more thyme syrup though, it was important to the dish and there was only a ridiculously tiny drizzle of it. 4rd Dessert Course: Butternut Squash Sorbet, Pumpkin Seed Cake, Chocolate Soil, Mole Paper I loved the flavor of the cake, although I wish it was slightly more dry and firm. I also loved the soil, and would gladly eat a bowl of it it with milk every morning. Unfortunately the sorbet really clashed texturally with everything else on the plate. I think it would have been better suited as an ice cream, which also would have subdued it's sweetness, which was mildly cloying. The mole paper was impossible to taste, which is a bummer because I really wanted to taste it! 5th Dessert Course: Caramelized Banana, Stout Foam, Smoked Chocolate Ice Cream This had a very interesting and chalenging flavor profile. The guiness for the foam had not been reduced or decanted at all, so it carried alot of hops and sourness, which really battled with the abundant smokiness of the ice cream for dominance of the tongue. Bananas...well I hate banana in desserts, so It's not really fair for me to even judge. I think I would have really liked the ice cream alone, but the foam just wasn't doing it for me. 1st Additional Dessert: Braised Pineapple, Mustard Ice Cream, Coconut Foam Cooked pineapple has a really peculiar taste that I've never fully been able to wrap my palate around. I liked the ice cream pretty well, but with the pineapple, everything was SO bright and SO acerbic. If the foam was a little more coconut-y it might have helped cut the sourness, I really couldn't taste it. It was a huge helping of pineapple too, and looked kind of heaped on the plate. A strange dish, and one that I'm not sure if I liked or not. I think it would have benefited from something mealy and earthy, like pine nuts, soy nuts, or some type of grain or rice. It felt a little unraveled. 2nd Additional Dessert: Chocolate Mousse and Orange Tuille "Birthday Candle" First of all, as a pastry chef, I looked at this and instantly thought "Hello! How could nobody have thought of this before?!?" The tuille formed a cylidrical "lamp shade" which enrobed the candle atop the chocolate base. Godamn ingenius and pretty damn tasty too! Petit Fours: Red Pepper Gelee, Chocolate Curry Almonds The almonds are still great, and the red pepper is a nice addition; a pate de fruit that actually isn't too sweet. DISCLAIMER: I feel the need to be totally objective when reviewing food, but I don't mean to come across as snide. Wylie and Sam take a lot of chances with their direction, and more often than not the result is something delicious and more importantly stimulating--inspirational even. I have tons of respect for what they do, regardless of whether I love every single dish they produce.