lavagna is middle of the road.. better than 90% of the italian nyc has to offer, and at it's price, it's hard not to love.. i eat dinner there almost every friday night, as everything seems to come together between the room, food, and service.. that said, i've eaten the same pasta dish there every time i've gone, without fail.. my girlfriend similarly has the kitchen make their version of her favorite pasta dish 9 times out of 10.. it's good.. not earth shattering, nor would it rank amongst the best italian in nyc, in my opinion.. i'd include il mulino, ideally at lunch, as others have mentioned.. lupa is my current favorite (no big suprise).. for a bowl of pasta, hit the little italian pepe rosso joint just south of houston on thompson or sullivan, i happen to love their vodka sauce.. i've had an awful experience at gigino.. so much so that even though it's in my neighborhood, i trek to the east village for dinner over hitting it again..