After reading this thread, I have to throw my two cents in. I am currently a smoker, I have tried to quit twice. In college, my best friend from New Jersey (a Malboro Red smoker), taught me how to play pool at the neighborhood bar. I picked up on the game and for many years played in pool leagues at neighborhood bars, bars one could walk to and walk home from. I enjoyed my Thursday night competitions and my weekend socializing with my fellow working "class" buddies. During this time I was single and needed a place to go to blow off the work steam, laugh and kick ass on the pool table. Smoking was still legal and a non-issue. The California smoking ban came along and most bars complied. The neighborhood bars (windowless dives) switched to disposable ashtrays and opaque cups with water. A DA in my county pursued these bars and fined them to the point where they eventually had to comply. I agree with Bourdain that everyone needs a place to go to relax with a drink and a smoke. There is comfort to be found in windowless dives that is integral to America and should not be allowd to become extinct. I agree that smoking bothers some people. Most all of the folks at these types of establishments know that smoking is part of the package and they smoke themselves, or they don't mind profiting from their smoking clientele. Personally, if I was trying to quit again, I would not want to be around smokers and could not drink either. Shooting pool with out a cigarette would be a tough one as well. So when I decide to quit again I will have to forgo pool and drink for awhile. Until then, my friend who is a bartender, calls me up and lets me know when the bar is slow so I can shoot pool with her and other smokers at my leisure. The law in NY will stick as it has in CA, businesses and people will adjust. There are a couple of cities (or towns) in both Northern and Southern CA that forbid smoking outside in their towns. This to me is extremist and elitiest. I try to openly smoke in these cities whenever I visit. This snobishness I can do without. I can also do without being itentified as a "smoker". I consider myself to be a polite smoker. I can't stand it when my smoking friends throw their buts on my porch, patio or into my garden. Why can't they ask where the ashtray is? Why do I have to tell them, after finding a butt or two, to please use the ashtray?! Also, why if after having not seen me for a while, so my friends/associates comment on the fact that I am or am not smoking? Why does that have to be the topic of discussion? I usually have to shut them down right there and change the subject. Often times when meeting new people I hold back from smoking so that they can see that I am a smart, thoughtful person. I can't count how many times I have heard, "You don't look like a smoker!" Well, I yam what I yam, when I yam.