I think I can further catagorize ice cream into "mass produced" (ben & jerry's, breyer's, other store bought), "batch frozen" or "homemade" (boutique ice cream shops, independent mom & pops, handmade with real fresh fruit), and "made at home" (on your own freezer with eggs at home). These are 3 different animals, and it's interesting to compare. In terms of superiority in flavor and texture, you can't beat batch frozen, mom and pop style ice cream shops. They strike a delicate balance of the homemade, handcrafted quality with the knowledge, equipment, and experience of a mass producer. Sure, sometimes some shops aren't that good, but on the whole they should know what they're doing. Mass produced ice creams are decent quality, but for as much image that Ben & Jerry's still portrays that theirs is "homemade," it's not. It's made in mass quantities by faceless machines operated by minimum wage earners. After all these years, they've still managed to keep their homey marketing, even after selling out to The Man. Ice cream in upper end restaurants are fantastic, but it's not the same, either. You can't just walk up to the counter and order; you have to sit down and have a full meal, for the most part, then get your dessert. Not a place to bring out the family or SO for ice cream. Also, to get reallly technical, Ben & Jerry's is not premium ice cream... it's superpremium. Haagen Dazs is superpremium. Breyer's and Baskin Robbins is premium. See the difference?