This is a little bit criss-cross to your question, but all of my tri-ply stainless pans are SLT (6 qt. dutch oven, three skillets, a couple of sauce pans), and I like them enough that I've given them as gifts. I very much like the second handle on my 12" skillet (which I got significantly enough on sale a couple of weeks ago that I'm going to time any additional purchases for those sales). The 12" skillet was my first cookware addition in five years or so, and it seems to be of at least the same quality as my earlier purchases. I don't have any non-stick pans, so can't comment on those. I have not spent enough time cooking on All Clad to know how anything I've said above compares and have not used any SLT anodized (my other cookware is early 90s Calphalon). I have found my stainless harder to clean than I expected based on what I'd read (then again, I'm not the world's most perfect dish washer), but agree that it's only an inconvenience that doesn't at all tempt me to upgrade to All Clad. And cleaning has been significantly less of an issue since I started keeping Bar Keeper's Friend on hand. That all having been said, in your shoes, I'd be perfectly happy trying out the SLT anodized.