Correct me if I'm wrong, but the real point is that we live in a democracy, and as such under both the Canadian and American Charter of rights, do have what is known as Freedom of Choice. While smoking may be bad for you, and the people around you etc, the fact is, it is still legal and consumers spending money should have a choice of whether to patronize a smoking or non smoking establishment. Why can't bar owners and restauranters choose one or the other, or offer a separate area for smokers. I live in Ontario, Canada, and our smoking bylaws in this province are certainly not equal across the board. In Toronto, you can have a separately ventilated area for smoking in dining rooms, and places can declare themselves a bar and permit smoking,but no one is allowed in under 19. In Mississauga, the same rule, and yet right beside Mississauga, in Oakville, there is no smoking, period unless your business is a bingo hall (go figure). In Burlington, no smoking in dining rooms, but ok in bars. The result is, smokers spend their money elsewhere, so businesses lose. When they make smoking illegal, fine. But there isn't any government I know of who is willing to give up the huge tax revenues generated, so they shouldn't be controlling your freedom of choice.