My parents ate here last year when they visited NYC. My stepfather adored their prime rib. My mother had some sort of salmon dish that she also thought quite delicious. Please take into consideration that my folks are just regular old non-foodies, so their tastes are fairly simple. However, they know when things are improperly cooked, and they know when things just don't work, and neither of these were the case. They quite enjoyed it, actually. Oh, and apparently they make a great Caesar salad.