Go busboy! I agree whole-heartedly. I would also like to reinforce S-tran's point. We must be critical of information, even when it is presented by a somewhat ("The classic wine and cheese party should become a thing of the past, if US research is to be believed."??) objective source such as the BBC. In order to extrapolate a study's conclusions the study sample must be representative of the population it is sampled from. In this case I would not consider the 11 panel members (mostly, if not all graduate students) necessarily representative of the general population of wine drinkers, the cheeses selected not representative of the cheeses typically chosen in fine wine and cheese pairings (mozzarella or Stilton with Pinot Noir?), nor the wines representative of all wines or even all red wines used in traditional wine and cheese pairings. Most people do not randomly choose wines and cheeses to pair together so the population of wines and cheeses might more appropriately be classic, traditional or least previously documented wine and cheese pairs. I know some of the details of this research which make me sceptical of the far-reaching conclusions stated in the article. In general, much of the research done in the Viticulture & Enology department at UC Davis is based on wines donated by generous wineries. We did/do not have the budget to go buy bottles of Sauternes or Jurancons to include in a study. Dr. Hildegard funded the purchase of cheeses but these were inexpensive Mozzarella, emmental, etc, NOT farm-made Camembert, Roquefort or Humbolt Fog. The cheeses were stored from one week to the next by vacuum-packing. Already, all of these factors do not make for ideal conditions, but at no point did they even attempt to include a classic wine and cheese pairing such as a strong salty blue cheese and a Sauternes. Finally when I pair wines and cheeses I am looking for a synergistic effect. It is obvious, and even desirable, that the cheese will affect our perception of the wine. Classically, fat globules will coat the salivary proteins in the lining of your mouth and interfere with their binding by tannins, making a red wine appear less astringent. A cheese course at the end of a meal is not meant to be a forum for an objective evaluation of a wine. Concluding from this study whether or not one should serve wine and cheese together is missing the point of the research. Dr. Hildegard states "The research wasn't about bad or good combinations. We were instead looking at cheeses that may or may not affect the flavour of the wine." The conclusion that cheeses, particularly strongly-flavoured cheeses, do affect the flavour and mouth-feel of red wine should not be surprising. Making broader conclusions than that is not possible based on the reasons stated above. This study is just one of a whole series that Dr. Heymann is hoping to do with wines and cheeses and other foods. I feel that there is definite value in these types of studies; we just have to be careful how far we extrapolate the conclusions. American public agencies do not support alcohol-related research so UC Davis' wine research is all done with private funding (compare with the Australians). I'm sure if any of you out there are interested in helping to support research on (food and) wine the Viticulture & Enology department at UC Davis would be more than happy to hear from you. Viticulture and Enology Wickson Hall UC Davis Davis, CA 95616 Thanks for letting me get my 2 cents in. Cheers, Lisa M.S. Viticulture & Enology