I have lived in New York and Singapore, and I would reluctantly rate New York ahead of Singapore (this despite having grown up in Singapore!). As a qualification, when I think of New York City, I think of the whole of New York City, and not just Manhattan; this includes the whole swathe of Brooklyn, Queens the Bronx and Staten Island. The breadth and depth of cuisine in New York City, both in terms of geographical reach and socio-economic range, is breathtaking. The foods of Asia, Central America, South America, Africa, Europe (and American, of course) are amply represented in all their variety. There are so many ethnic communities in New York City that have contributed their culinary heritage to our dining delight. Many of these can be found outside of Manhattan, but still within New York City. Excellent eating can be quite easily found at every level, from street food to haute cuisine. The dining scene is simply vibrant. Okay, I will admit that the Chinese dining scene is not as refined or sophisticated as that in Hong Kong or even Singapore, but it is still bustling with good food and good variety (after all, there is a Chinatown in each of Manhattan, Queens and Brooklyn). We still talking about one out of dozens (maybe hundreds) of other cuisines available in New York City. I love eating in Singapore, and wonderful eats are abundantly available. But Singapore simply does not have the breadth and depth of New York. The range of cuisines in Singapore is definitely more limited, for one thing. You would be hard pressed to find any South American restaurants, except for the Brazilian churascaria that is now almost ubiquitous in any big city, for example. Greek, Ukranian, Afghan and Spanish restaurants are not easy to come by. And given it's location, there isn't even a comprehensive representation of South East Asian or regional Chinese cuisines in Singapore (I had better Vietnamese food in New York, for example, and I don't know if there is any Burmese restaurants in Singapore). There isn't a good range of regional Chinese cuisines in Singapore either. There isn't a Xinjiang or Uighur restaurant in Singapore to my knowledge, nor are there many (if any) good Sichuan, Hebei or Dongbei restuarants. There are also not many good high-end restaurants in Singapore. Most of the new aspirants all lack something, whether it is in terms of food quality, service or ambience. And they are not cheap either. There just aren't the various levels of dining experiences available in Singapore as there are in New York. The best eating in Singapore, for me, is mostly found in the humble hawker centres and coffee shops. At this level of dining, I think that Singapore is almost impossible to beat. The sheer variety of cheap, freshly prepared, tasty dishes available in these eating places is astonishing and I have many favorites - laksa, chinese rice, fried guotiao, roasted pork rice, fishball noodles, nasi lemak, hokkien prawn noodles, popiah, pork rib soup, barbequed seafood, etc etc. And I adore peranakan cuisine, which is a fusion of chinese and malay cuisines. So I think Singapore and New York are both great world food cities, but I will have to give the nod to New York on balance.