kazuo

MJS: I don't know the place you've described, but here are a couple of options (all in the "piece by piece, cook to order" vein): Hayashi 03-3241-5367: small shop, one seating only, located in Nihonbashi and hard to find (I still get lost), you eat what the master deems best Yamazato 03-3582-0111: has the advantage of being located in the Hotel Okura, so finding it is no problem, ask specifically for the tempura counter, if you order a set, the chefs will show you what they're going to serve and you can substitute items that you dislike There are also a couple of chains with many shops throughout Tokyo, Tsunahachi being the lower budget place and Ten'ichi being the more upscale. Well executed tempura is generally a bit of a luxury, expect to pay somewhere in the neighborhood of 15,000-20,000 yen (more if you opt for Hayashi) per person. I'm sure you know this already, but if you're going to a shop that you've not been to before, you may want to request that they fax a map to your office/hotel. Have fun.

We keep a good stock of Menetou Salon and Muscadet. I second the earlier recommendations for the 04 Roulot Bourgogne Blanc and the 04 Leflaive Bourgogne (we still have some of the 92 and 96 Leflaive Bourgogne Blanc, both of which are still drinking beautifully). Also worth looking for are the Villaine Rully and the Cote Chalonnaise Les Clous.

Jim: Those Thomas pinots are something else, aren't they? They're hard to come by in Tokyo, but when I see them, I buy. Really lovely wines. I also wanted to thank you for your notes on the 2004 Villaine Cote Chalonnaise Les Clous. Your notes were so evocative that I had to try the wine, loved it and bought all I could find here in Tokyo. Should do well as the house pour starting in the summer of 08.

With assorted sushi and other nibbles: 96 Egly Ouriet With roast beef, veg, etc.: 99 Lafarge Volnay Vendages Selection and 97 Insignia With assorted cheeses and desserts: 97 Cuvee Constance and 01 Yquem (the latter sacrificed in the name of science, of course)

Jim: Nice wines indeed. Glad to see the 99 Grands showing well after all the concern about its relative youth; I suspect it had been decanted rather far in advance. The 82 Lafleur has taken a while to come around, but I agree that the best examples (like your bottle) are magnificent. FYI, the 85 Krug has been recently re-released and a few bottles remain in the shop downstairs from your office. Did you source the Huet there as well? I hope January 20 goes as well as this night did.

Agreed re Imai-ya. Our office uses it all the time for various get togethers. Some others to consider on the upscale-ish side: Bird Land (Ginza): 5250-1081, superior raw materials, quite a bit of attitude, still some of the best yakitori I've ever had. Easily accessible from Roppongi via the Hibiya line. Shamo-sho (Nishi Azabu): 3498-3271, not a yakitori-ya per se, but has excellent shamo yakitori. Easy walk from the Grand Hyatt. Both places will require reservations in advance, Bird Land much more so than Shamo-sho. I still prefer to wander down to Yurakucho or Shinbashi and walk into the smokiest, noisiest place I can find. Enjoy.

Now that is some fabulous gyu tataki. Wow. Do you ever use bincho-tan in an outdoor grill for tataki, or is it too much trouble unless you're cooking other things? I've found that the bincho-tan imparts a bit more char and smokiness than a gas burner. Have you ever tried toro salmon tataki? Roughly the same concept as katsuo, but the fat content in the salmon makes for a very rich dish. We tend to serve it with momiji oroshi, which might also go well with the gyu tataki.

Interesting selection of wines there. A friend has been after me to open some of the 2003 Clos de Papes; apparently it is getting quite a lot of hype on the Squires board. Our impressions were similar to yours, we decanted it for an hour (although I did sneak a glass when I opened it and found the wine surprisingly forward). By the end of the evening (total of about 4 hours from the initial decanting), I thought the raisiny, roasted fruit quality was starting to get overwhelming. The 2003 vintage in France seems to have produced a lot of atypically big wines. Have not had any bords yet (and don't plan to), but we also opened a 2003 Roumier Chambolle Musigny (village), and my initial reaction was "hey, who poured the Loring in my glass?" Quite atypical for Roumier, I thought, and we opened the 99, 00, 01 and 02 just to confirm. Lastly, how was Cuisine 219? Worthwhile for an offline? Did you have a chance to check out the wine list?

Sorry to be late in replying. I didn't find La Rochelle to be that good; perhaps I caught a bad day. If you are looking for Franco-Japanese, I would vote for Hotel de Mikuni. In any event though, enjoy your trip and let us know if you need any more info.

There are two pinned threads in the Japan forum, one covering restaurants in Kansai (which includes Kyoto), the other covering restaurants in Tokyo. There should be quite a lot of useful info in those threads. If there are particular types of food that you want to try, please let us know. By the way, I wouldn't recommend La Rochelle if you're referring to the restaurant owned by Iron Chef Sakai. If you have an interest in French food or Franco-Japanese, there are far better choices.

Only had a few of these as follows. 91 Montelena (12/04): gift from friends visiting from the US, superb balance and none of the over the top California cab opulence, had a strange green note mid palate that most of us attributed to travel shock (with burgers). 98 VT Le Crau (3/05): still hard and a bit hot, nose wasn't showing too much at first but then blossomed after about an hour (fine with lamb sandwiches). 96 St Hune (2/05): too young, reticent nose and all mineral, flint and iron on the palate at first, later crisp but the acidity seemed just a touch tough (with raw scallops, sea urchin and salmon roe over sushi rice). 99 St Innocent, Cristom and Drouhin (11/04): impromptu pinot tasting, all pretty good, St Innocent as Brad noted is a bit shut down but the evidence of good winemaking is there, but all paled compared to the Thomas reserve. 89 Lynch (4/05): seems to have lost some its youthful flashiness but is to me a better wine now, still lots of black fruit, cassis, etc. and better balance than before. Whatever you select, I hope you enjoy it.

Closing dinner with clients: 1993 Soldera BDM Reserve: beautiful mature Brunello, complex nose replete with spices and tobacco, balanced and mature 1991 Quintarelli Amarone: wow, all discussion at the table stopped and everyone dove into this, immense yet balanced Various other recent wines: 2001 Tua Rita Redigaffi: when first opened, not very attractive, unbalanced, vanilla oak sticking out like a sore thumb, after 15 hours in decanter, it is more integrated but a bit too jammy and sweet, not worth the money to me 1990 Giacosa Barolo Reserve (red label): a wine to savor, complex nose with classic tar, roses and dust, color is garnet with slight browning, builds strength as the night goes on, wow 1990 Gaja Sperss: by comparison to the Giacosa, seems a little coarse, more power than finesse 2001 Quinault l'Enclos: shut down and rather unattractive, nothing but coffee and vanilla oak at this point

Jim: Sounds like a great evening. My experience with the 97 BDM is that it benefits from a bit of decanting. My last 97 got better after 1 hour in the decanter and time in the glass. I know what you mean about this producer; best value (if such a thing exists) in white burgs. We're on the same page re the ZH gewurz, but am sorry the 90 Meyney did not show better for you. My most recent was showing its age, but still was beautiful to drink; lots of plums and power, with residual Cordier funk. If you ever find the 89 from a reputable source, it's better than the 90.

Only because here in Tokyo VT is quite a bit cheaper than most of the other CNDPs. The 1998 VT Le Crau was our house wine for a number of years, as we found it at a little less than USD300 per case. Had the 2000 Bosquet du Papes Cuvee Grenache and the 2000 Janasse Cuvee Chaupin last night. The Janasse is a wine to look for. Don't know how the 2003 will be, but the 2000 is really lovely.

2003, I am told, was a rather unseasonably hot year in the Rhone. I tasted through the Guigal La La's and found them freakishly large wines, high alcohol (but not hot), but drinkable even now. Production in the north was smaller than usual, so those wines (Hermitage, Cote Rotie, etc.) may be hard to find and expensive (even more so than usual). In Chateauneuf, many of my friends are buying up all they can fine, but I've found the wines are a little too big (I'd bet the luxury cuvees like Bonneau Celestins, Capo and Perrin are clocking in at 16% or more). I don't know what your budget is like or where you're now living, but here's a range of things that you might consider: Expensive (and I mean really expensive) Guigal La La's Chave Hermitage Pegau Cuvee de Capo Brunel Cuvee Centenaire Mid-range Beaucastel CNDP Pegau Cuvee Reserve Marcoux CNDP Clape Cornas Basics Guigal makes a basic line that is reasonable Vieux Telegraph CNDP Chateau de al Nerthe Apologies for not including St. Joseph, Cote d Rhone or other recs. I don't know enough about them in the 2003 vintage.