I'm surprised that nobody has any input on this. I've been very happy with my two Lodge enameled dutch ovens for over a year. I have only limited experience with comparable Le Creuset models that I've used in other kitchens, so I don't feel comfortable making any detailed comparison. I just checked on Amazon, and a 3 qt Lodge runs around $40 while a 3.5 qt Le Creuset will set you back a whopping $175. That's a huge cost difference for potentially similar items. It would seem important then to identify actual differences between Le Creuset and other manufacturers, especially because so many people on this thread have intimated that they have had to stretch their budgets to acquire these items. Cost-benefit analyses come up often in this part of the eG forums and are inherently subjective. A Vitamix blender costs much more than department store models but is clearly designed and built to different specifications; likewise a knife made from high-end Japanese steel versus the conventional French/German offerings. Every consumer will have to decide whether the difference in performance justifies the additional cost. In these two examples, we have specific information about what makes a low-cost product different from its high-cost brethren. As far as I know, this is not the case with enameled cast-iron pots. So, what are the tangible differences, if any? Otherwise, the amount saved by going with Lodge over Le Creuset could be put to better uses if it buys one nothing but a name. ← The first piece of enameled cast iron I bought was the dutch oven recommended by Cooks Illustrated as a best buy from Target. It was good but almost immediately the enamel started chipping off the handles. I then bought a Le Creuset second from Marshall's and haven't had any problems with chipping. I gave the Target dutch oven to Goodwill and started acquiring LC. Some of my pieces are thrift store finds and have years of use in them and none have chips or missing enamel. You might save more up front buying a cheaper brand but if you have to replace it every few years then the savings disappear. LC has a hundred year warranty so if anything goes wrong return it and get a new one for the cost of shipping. Chad