The number 9 bar IS the upstairs bar at the Evening Star. Although it is pretty cool, I would skip it in general because it is so sporadically open. I have been several times and very rarely is it open and I have not been able to get a good explanation about the hours, so if you want to go, call first. But, if they have an event that takes place there, or you want to rent a room, that would be a pretty good spot.