If I was to have 10 rums in a bar of all "Top Shelf" quality, what would some of you out there that know rum much better than I do choose. Here are some ground rules to consider when choosing: 1) Price is of NO object, but less than $400 I think is a good boundary. 2) As long as it's possible to get a bottle (even if rare) it can be added to the list. If it's impossible, let's keep it off. 3) Make sure that it meets a "Top Shelf" type standard 4) A few should WOW people. So, like Pyrat Cask 23 I think would be in and maybe even Mount Gay Tricentennial Rum (though I am not sure on it's availability) 5) Some good for the money runs could be added as well. I assume many will choose Ron Zacapa Cent. 23 and I would as well. I think it's a fantastic rum. So I guess that means we already have 2, we might need just 8 more. 1) Ron Zacapa Centanario 23 2) Pyrat Cask 23 (from what I have read on this board many think it is without peer. I think that qualifies to make this list) Thanks to all, let's see how this goes.