Thanks so much for all the feedback. I do not feel I could go the "whetstone" route, and chose instead to go with a professional knife sharpener, Bob Kramer at Bladesmith http://kramerknives.com/index.htm. He is a knife god, and he not only will sharpen knives and return them pretty quickly, but also makes custom carbon steel knives (1 year waiting list for knives that start at $400--he's going to be in Cooks Illustrated this month and has been in Saveur). I sent half my knives and they were extremely sharp--my plan is to use my steel each time I use the knives and send them back out to him once a year for professional sharpening. My formerly dull butter knives can slice paper now. I'm not going to use my old Chef's Choice any more.