I had my first dining experience at Nicholas this evening as we celebrated my wife's, Emily, 30th birthday. It was an outstanding night and definitely lived up to everyone's rave reviews. We both decided to go with the Early Winter three course menu. We started with an amuse of Roasted Chestnut Soup, I was tempted to see if I could substitute it for my first course. Emily started with the Rabbit Crepeinette, very tasty, but it seemed a bit heavy on the fennel. I had the Lobster and Saffron Soup, it was a tough decision between that and the Foie Gras, but the chill in the air made the decision easier. For the main course my wife opted for the Seared Duck Breast and I could tell by the look on her face it was excellent, she is a fan of duck and will only order it in the nicer establishments, she said it was the best she has ever had. I opted for the Red Wine Poached Fillet, I was not disappointed. The meat was so tender it could almost be cut with the fork, but the Red Wine sauce made the meal. We had been planning to try the cheese course before our desserts, but we were in no shape to eat anything else. I was very surprised at the generosity of the portions, although on normal occasions Emily and I don't normally eat dessert. After ordering dessert we received a treat of Leche-Nut Water with a Coconut Foam, it had a distinct citrus almost lime flavor, I was not a huge fan, but I don't like coconut. Emily found it refreshing. For dessert, Emily had the had the Pear Tart with a Walnut Glaze & Cinnamon Ice Cream, with a little birthday wish and a candle situated in a rasberry. I had the Warm Valrona Chocolate Cake with Pistachio Ice Cream, the thin crisp of pineapple was excellent as was the ice cream. Overall it was a very pleasant evening, the service was impeccable, yet not stuffy and the food was outrageous. The worst part of the meal was that it made me forget the wonderful dinner my sister-in-law treated us to the night before at Anthony David's in Hoboken. It was a wonderful meal, just not on the same level as Nicholas. I will definetly be going through withdrawl after those two meals this week