Ate at Johnny's Half Shell for the first time last night, with rbh and 4 others. Atmosphere-wise, it's a good place to go with friends -- it's not what we felt was a romantic-date restaurant. Two people got the soft shell crab, which they pronounced "really good... but also really small". To illustrate, they polished off an entire bread basket, got started on a second, AND were the only ones who needed to get dessert because they were still hungry. My husband and I both got the crabcakes -- we got two cakes that came with coleslaw and french fries. Although the crabcakes were on the small size, they were meaty and had only enough breading to hold it together. However, there's not too much flavoring. That's probably because you're expected to use the remoulade-like tartar sauce that's provided on the side, but I found it too overpowering. I love the taste of crab, so I was fine eating them sans sauce. The big disappointment was the shards of crab cartilage, which I think shouldn't be present in a $24 crabcake. The fries had a great flavor -- think thinner versions of Matchbox fries (they had that true potato flavor complemented by a judicious dusting of sea salt.) And the coleslaw was quite enjoyable, which was a pleasant surprise because I hate over-mayonnaised coleslaw and am always afraid that's what I'll get. (I really like KFC's coleslaw, but that's probably a whole other posting.) Happily, I couldn't have identified the mayo in last night's slaw, even if you'd paid me. If you're the type that does like creamy slaw, you'd have to pretend Johnny's is a "cabbage salad" in order to not be disappointed. I did manage to snare some of rbh's trout, but he'll have to post what he thought of it. Overall, it was good, but not really worth the money. I kept thinking of what I could get at Ray's the Steaks for the same price....