I joined this thread rather late, and I'm trying to remember everything I wanted to reply to ... forgive me if any of this repeats what may have already been said in other threads (boy, have I got some catching up to do!) For whomever was worried about copyright issues regarding recipes, don't -- recipes, as in a list of ingredients, cannot be copyrighted, although the text that surrounds them can. If you just want to post a recipe or recipes for comparison, knock yourself out and rest easy. With regards to Torani Amer, I think it's terrific stuff, and I've been using it not only in original recipes but as a substitute for Amer Picon in old cocktails that call for it, including Picon Punch (the recipe for which is actually printed on the Torani Amer front label). I still haven't tasted original Amer Picon, but I shall soon. There has been a bit of disagreement over on the DrinkBoy forum: the eminent Dr. Cocktail finds the Torani product to be superior to the current version of true Amer Picon, which has changed its original formula and dropped its proof by half. However, "DrinkBoy" Robert (*wave*) has done side-by-side tastings and evaluations of both (the original full-proof Picon, that is) and has found that while they're both good products they were actually different enough such that he didn't consider Torani to be an acceptable substitute. That said, I have been using Torani in old recipes that call for Amer Picon, and different as though the cocktail may be I've been happy with the results. I'm really looking forward to doing by own taste tests (and I can't wait to see what a Hoskins Cocktail tastes like with real Amer Picon). Regarding maraschino, as much as I was in love with the Luxardo product I'm really liking Maraska better, primarily because it's drier (and not to mention the fact that it's a lot cheaper!) Regarding cherries for garnish, if you can't find that fabuloso-sounding Italian product, we've been enjoying the "Maraska Cocktail Cherries" sold at Williams-Sonoma. Expensive (as is everything there), but with a good cherry flavor and real cherry color (i.e., not neon red). I got a neat tip from Daniel, a local cocktailian bartender who has a website and business called Vintage Cocktails -- pour out the "juice" from your supermarket maraschino cherries and dump them into a colander; rinse the living crap out of them, then put them back in the jar and cover with Maraschino liqueur. This works amazingly well, and the cherries get better day by day. Um. I think that's it. Chuck