I'm disappointed to hear so many people have had bad experiences at Oliveto. Every time I've eaten there everything has been absolutely fantastic - impeccable service, amazing food. My only complaint is the wine list - I think it's fairly limited. I wish they would try to stock a little more in the way of older vintages. But I've still had many great wines there, and even been introduced to some of my now-favorites. I think some of the best service I've ever had was the first time I ate there. I was a poor college student, and a friend and I saved up for a couple of months to take a long weekend in Oakland and be decadent. We sat at that little bar area upstairs, and the waiter was incredibly attentive to us all night, making suggestions, bringing out little tastes of stuff from the kitchen, and so on all night. It was amazing.