Cafe Sultan is in the parking lot behind Starbucks/Talbots on Valley Road in Upper Montclair. It's a small, comfortable BYO in the space that used to house California Pizza (I think). We love their food -- great hummus, lamb, kefta, salads, stews. The menu isn't extensive, but they usually have a couple of specials every night. I think it's fairly inexpensive for the area. We can have a nice meal for under $20/person. My husband and I almost always go early because we have a one-year old and want to disturb as few people as possible, so we never need a reservation. It usually starts to get crowded after about 8.