Thanks for all the replies. A lot of interesting ideas! It never occurred to me to throw spiced rum in the mix, but it sounds delicious. The age range of the party is around 18-24, and most of my friends probably wouldn't appreciate an Old Fashioned, unfortunately. However, it's not gonna be massive, so more intensive drinks aren't out of the question. I'm gonna try some of the Old Fashioneds this weekend though... Keep em coming! I'd drink anything you guys have offered so far.