Hello egullet, Surfed this sight for a while but this is my first reply. So, this one is for Fatguy. Generally, I have respected your opinion on critiques and what not. On the Per Se issue you seem to have a strong opinion of Bruni's failure. So I propose that you write a post to egullet as though it were your article for the NYT. Therefore, you could illustrate by comparison how you feel a four star review should have read. I have to say, as well, that I feel Bruni has been dropping the ball at some points in various reviews, but the Per Se review was "acceptable." So, if your game, can't wait to read it.
