Jump to content
  • Welcome to the eG Forums, a service of the eGullet Society for Culinary Arts & Letters. The Society is a 501(c)3 not-for-profit organization dedicated to the advancement of the culinary arts. These advertising-free forums are provided free of charge through donations from Society members. Anyone may read the forums, but to post you must create a free account.

Philadelphia Tasters' Club


Vadouvan

Recommended Posts

Well, it looks like this is shaping up nicely....

will we be informed about time, place and requirements to participate?

Sandy Smith, Exile on Oxford Circle, Philadelphia

"95% of success in life is showing up." --Woody Allen

My foodblogs: 1 | 2 | 3

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rosengarten mentions the method of pouring some oil directly into your cupped palm, taught to him by Marcella Hazan, but then says that wine glasses will probably be more practical... also mentions chunks of bread (and water) as palate cleansers.

btw, rosengarten's latest shipment of oils for his "fresh pressed olive oil club" are freaking outstanding (imho -- i'm no expert). really rich, much more so than previous shipments. and they have pressing dates on the bottles of this past november, as in two months ago.

info about this latest batch of oils is here.

might be fun to see if you can convince them to contribute some bottles, 703.394.4931 is the phone number

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Here are some of my notes from olive oil tasting classes at Ital.cook.

Vadouvan: you are 100% right...apples and sparking water. And be prepared to want to drink a lot of red wine afterwards, to clean the pipes.

Depending on when you are doing the tasting, I'd love to be involved. If possible.

ORGANOLEPTIC SENSATIONS TYPICAL OF EXTRA VIRGIN OLIVE OIL:

Fruity: aroma reminiscent of the smell and taste of olive (green or ripe): can be light, medium or intense.

Bitter: taste, more or less pleasant according to degree of intensity, of oil obtained from green olives.

Sharp: pungent sensation (from the poly phenols) typical of green, or barely ripe, olives.

Sweet: smooth, pleasant taste of an oil where bitter or sharp tastes are not predominant

Other positive sensations: apple, grass, almond, leaf, tomato, pine nut, walnut, artichoke etc…

Man cannot, in any way, improve the natural quality of an oil: it will be at its best when all the phases of production have been carried out correctly (growing, general health of the olives, ripening time, harvesting and conservation of the olives, processing, conservation of the oil).

Any error or unfortunate circumstance, occurring in any of these phases can negatively influence, even severely, the quality of the end product (defects will be apparent).

MAIN DEFECTS OF EXTRA VIRGIN OLIVE OIL:

Mold: comes from olives where fungi and yeasts have developed because of damp conditions

Heated: comes from olives which have been stored for too long in deep layers or in sacks and have undergone fermentation (mainly lactic).

Winey or vinegary: comes from olives that have undergone alcoholic or vinegar fermentation.

Marc: characteristic aroma from oil which has been in contact with its own lees for too long.

Rancid: characteristic aroma of oxidized oils exposed to air, light and high temperatures.

Regards,

Judith

Link to comment
Share on other sites

R. Evan Turney, Exec Chef at Mercato and Valanni, might be an excellent person to chat with at this tatsing, since he offers daily "flights" of olive oils at Mercato.

Rich Pawlak

 

Reporter, The Trentonian

Feature Writer, INSIDE Magazine
Food Writer At Large

MY BLOG: THE OMNIVORE

"In Cerveza et Pizza Veritas"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interesting, by daily flights , the oils change every day ?

That statement certainly helps to develop the idea.

I am proceeding from actual oil tasting to 3 dishes of which olive oil is an actual pivotal component.

I feel like any dish that falls into that category should have no more than 3 components max.

Thoughts anyone ?

Has anyone ever had an "olive risotto".

I am thinking standard risotto with lucques or arbequina, parmesan and doused with green spicy olive oil tableside.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interesting, by daily flights , the oils change every day ?

That statement certainly helps to develop the idea.

I am proceeding from actual oil tasting to 3 dishes of which olive oil is an actual pivotal component.

I feel like any dish that falls into that category should have no more than 3 components max.

Thoughts anyone ?

Has anyone ever had an "olive risotto".

I am thinking standard risotto with lucques or arbequina, parmesan and doused with green spicy olive oil tableside.

See, a chat with chef Turney might be in order!

And yes, the flights are a daily special at Mercato, and sometimes very very interesting

Rich Pawlak

 

Reporter, The Trentonian

Feature Writer, INSIDE Magazine
Food Writer At Large

MY BLOG: THE OMNIVORE

"In Cerveza et Pizza Veritas"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am proceeding from actual oil tasting to 3 dishes of which olive oil is an actual pivotal component.

I feel like any dish that falls into that category should have no more than 3 components max.

Thoughts anyone ?

Maybe some sort of pureed white bean soup with a nice drizzle of oil?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

hey v, pomme puree using olive oil as the main blending ingredient?

actually, that may be repetative after the risotto, but i've found mashed potato to really show truffle oil and walnut oil well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have a problem with tiramisu. I don't know how it should taste. Every restaurant seems to interpret it differently. So how do I recognize the best tiramisu? For me, tiramisu is like art; I know what I like. But I have no idea what Italy's tiramisu savant considers to be an ideal tiramisu.

So it is that I wonder about an olive oil tasting. Is there an ideal olive oil? What are its traits?

I remember a eureka moment with wine - my first wine tasting where two different wines were paired with the same dish. Could it be the same with olive oils? Perhaps comparing the taste and contribution of various olive oils as part of the same dish. Different olive oils may be best with different dishes. Not sure if that is what V. is suggesting, but it makes sense to me.

Edited by Holly Moore (log)

Holly Moore

"I eat, therefore I am."

HollyEats.Com

Twitter

Link to comment
Share on other sites

V, I have done my own olive oil tasting, So I will send you my results.

A good ways to test olive oils is one set up a duel tasting. First I think that you should taste the olive oil by themselves first. Then use the same olive oil in a simple dish. Something clean, too much starch will color the oil. Another good way is to do a side by side comparison of Spanish vs, French, or Greek vs Italian. Or just pick one counrty and go with it. I feel that the french are very calm, well rounded oils, the Spanish oils like the Italians oils can smack you right in the face with the "greeness of the fruit".

It depends what region or climate you are looking at. Also iF you can find whether or not the olive was stone pressed or was was it pressed by a hydrolic machine. Were the olives hand picked, or machine picked. (olives are a lot like grapes the more they get banged around starts the process of extruding the oils, they can ferment causeing a heat bulid up) .

V I will send you my notes on the subject they maybe helpful. Check with Jack at downtown, he's got a good selection. Aslo talk to Tod he's got some great oils we sold him.

Holly I have a very good recipe for Tiramisu. I too often find that many restaurants have too varied tiramasu. Too wet, or too dry, too much alchohol, or not enough. I worked with some Italians over the past 3 years. I have a very good recipe for you, but it requires a larger amount so you may have to scale it down.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Andrew Fenton :

Maybe some sort of pureed white bean soup with a nice drizzle of oil?

Andrew, I feel even something so seemingly simple like that would mask the flavor.

In order to develop the flavor of a white bean soup, you need strong aromatics, Mirepoix plus garlic for one, Smoked ham hocks or shanks and for ultimate flavor, duck fat as the cooking oil for sweating the mirepoix. Olive oil garnish would be mostly visual, in order to make a flavor contribution to such a soup, I would go the route of an extra virgin hazelnut or pistachio oil like the keller oils. I feel like dishes should not suffer for thier garnishes.

And that's the whole point, garnishes as opposed to garnishes that are a lynchpin of flavor.

Although I am thinking some kind of Crudo-sashimi type thing would be great, I poured through my library and though I am loathe to reproduce recipes, there is an interesting dish in the Tesuya book.

Raw Scallop with tomato sorbet, this would be perfect for a fruity ripe Olio.

Here it is on Amazon, you can even peek inside :

http://www.amazon.com/Tetsuya-Recipes-Aust...f/dp/1580082947

WKL:

ey v, pomme puree using olive oil as the main blending ingredient?

actually, that may be repetative after the risotto, but i've found mashed potato to really show truffle oil and walnut oil well.

Again Bill, Same theory as above, mashed potatoes always need cream and butter or in my opinion its garbage, once it's totally smooth, it needs butter (maybe not the proportions Murkury uses at Ze Atelier... :laugh: ).

However two things would work well.

1. Pomme Ecrasee with chervil.

2. An Italian "potato Salad". Boiled in skins, cut open,salt, pepper, red vinegar and heavily doused with olive oil while it is steaming.

MatthewJ:

V, I have done my own olive oil tasting, So I will send you my results.

A good ways to test olive oils is one set up a duel tasting. First I think that you should taste the olive oil by themselves first. Then use the same olive oil in a simple dish. Something clean, too much starch will color the oil. Another good way is to do a side by side comparison of Spanish vs, French, or Greek vs Italian. Or just pick one counrty and go with it. I feel that the french are very calm, well rounded oils, the Spanish oils like the Italians oils can smack you right in the face with the "greeness of the fruit".

It depends what region or climate you are looking at. Also iF you can find whether or not the olive was stone pressed or was was it pressed by a hydrolic machine. Were the olives hand picked, or machine picked. (olives are a lot like grapes the more they get banged around starts the process of extruding the oils, they can ferment causeing a heat bulid up) .

V I will send you my notes on the subject they maybe helpful. Check with Jack at downtown, he's got a good selection. Aslo talk to Tod he's got some great oils we sold him.

Thanks Matt, what kinda oils did you sell Tod /

I generally despise greek olive oils, they tend to get rancid quickly, I am trying to get my hands on a Nyons Olive oil ?

Any Ideas ?

I remember Jack used to sell them , I think you and I were the only people who bought it ?

http://www.domainerocheville.com/olivea.html

Edited by Vadouvan (log)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jack doesn't sell Nyon anymore? That sucks. I sold tod two french oils. both slightly flavored. But the interesting thing is that the flavor was pressed with the olive, not infused after. SO the oil is very friuty and round like a French oil, but has subtle flavors of Basil, and thyme and rosemary.

My parents came back from greece with a greek oil that was more redolent of Spanish oil. Green, but did not kick me in the balls. Some oils I thick would be worth a shot

Picual

Hoja blanca

Verdial

Arbequina

Empeltre

corniciabra

Lucques is also one of my favorites.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

youneed to come down here, and check out what we buy directly from France. Side note: If anyone is interested i eating great Perigord Truffles, Not that chemically truffle oil, or the Bourdeux truffles. Shuffle over to Twenty Twenty one. We just sold him 2# of gorgeous truffles. He probalbly has the only perigodines in the city. And I know his cooking is quite good. No gaseous elements involved

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On the olive oil subject-- Friends had brought us back olive oil from Marrakesh that was the best I've ever had. The writing was in Arabic, so I don't know the name.

Does anyone know of some good Morrocan olive oil that cen be sourced in Philly/Montco?

"Love and cook with reckless abandon" - Dalai Lama

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Holly I have a very good recipe for Tiramisu.  I too often find that many restaurants have too varied tiramasu.  Too wet, or too dry, too much alchohol, or not enough.  I worked with some Italians over the past 3 years. I have a very good recipe for you, but it requires a larger amount so you may have to scale it down.

Would be interested taking a look at it. No problem scaling it down if I have to, but we're talking tiramisu, so that might not be necessary.

Holly Moore

"I eat, therefore I am."

HollyEats.Com

Twitter

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Olive oil tasting seemed to be fun if not completely scientific.

Thanks to all who actually replied and showed up last night.

Phil A. will be posting the pics and further comments by other attendees.

We just randomly chose 13 oils that we had access to, we all decided that a more focused tasting of 6 to 8 oils would be more coincise.

Oils were as follows.

1.Dibruno Frutatto

2.Marques De Valdueza

3.Le Moulins Mahjoub

4.Novello / Marc Vetri

5.Carm

6.Yellingbo

7.Frantoia

8.Aguibal Manzanilla

9.Aguibal Arbequina

10.Becchina Olio Verde

11.Armando Manni Per Me

12.Armando Manni Per Me Figlio

13.Planeta

Clearly there are some great oils out there we wanted to gather but they are way more expensive. Iwould like to see Geraci, Nunez De Prado and Laudemio in the next tasting.

Tasting was structured as

Smell/Aroma

Color

Flavor

Heat sensitivity

Affinity with food.

SMELL / AROMA

I decided to go with the Amplifier, It pushes aroma's further foward than any other glass and has the best functional swirl.

COLOUR and FLAVOR

We used plastic inert 2 oz crytal clear cups.

Philadinings new flourescent rig highlighted the room perfectly.

HEAT SENSITIVITY

Using a standard graduted flask, we heated up the oil with a hot air gun, temp was monitored with infra-red thermometer.

Basically compared samples of the same oils with a 20 to 30 degree difference.

Makes a big difference.

More comments about this when the "Risotto of Nothing" is discussed.

FOOD AFFINITY

We decided to see the impact of Olive oil on various types of food and assembled a variety of small tastes to see the contribution of olive oil at the end.

All dishes had olive oil added to the plate at the end.

One could then taste the dish before and after the addition of oil.

The dishes were as follows.

Onaga Ceviche. Tomato-Tarragon Sorbet. Fennel. Mint. Cilantro. Aji Panca.

Grilled Pane Rustica. Bincho-Tan Charcoal. Pesto

Warm Burratta. Red Orach. Sea Salt. Black Pepper

Risotto of Nothing. Parmesan.

Lentil Stew. Chick Pea. Iberico Chorizo, Iberico Salsichon, Finochiona, Piquillo. Esplette. Benton Bacon.

Mozzarella Ice Cream. Black Olive Sugar.

Comments will follow after Phil's Pics.

More Shenanigans

While the stoves were hot, we figure we would take a stab at the chicken issue.

We cooked a bluefoot and Eberly Chicken exactly the same way and did a side by side comparison.

Everyone immediately picked the bluefoot within 3 bites.

Chickens were both :

Breast Meat Only.

3 Grams of Maldon Salt each.

CSV with 2oz Olive Oil 58C 2 Hrs.

Seared Black Steel Pan/ Grapeseed oil.

Again, more commentary from attendees and Phil.

This was fun.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Olive oil tasting seemed to be fun if not completely scientific.

Thanks to all who actually replied and showed up last night.

Phil A. will be posting the pics and further comments by other attendees.

We just randomly chose 13 oils that we had access to, we all decided that a more focused tasting of 6 to 8 oils would be more coincise.

Oils were as follows.

1.Dibruno Frutatto

gallery_23992_4186_46114.jpg

2.Marques De Valdueza

gallery_23992_4186_21992.jpggallery_23992_4186_890.jpg

3.Les Moulins Mahjoub

gallery_23992_4186_33524.jpg

4.Novello / Marc Vetri

gallery_23992_4186_1815.jpg

5.Carm

gallery_23992_4186_38746.jpg

6.Yellingbo

gallery_23992_4186_18813.jpg

7.Frantoia

gallery_23992_4186_29846.jpg

8.Aguibal Manzanilla

gallery_23992_4186_53872.jpg

9.Aguibal Arbequina

gallery_23992_4186_55828.jpg

10.Becchina Olio Verde

gallery_23992_4186_48097.jpg

11.Armando Manni Per Me

gallery_23992_4186_29513.jpg

12.Armando Manni Per Me Figlio

gallery_23992_4186_16714.jpg

13.Planeta

gallery_23992_4186_22898.jpg

Clearly there are some great oils out there we wanted to gather but they are way more expensive. Iwould like to see Geraci, Nunez De Prado and Laudemio in the next tasting.

Tasting was structured as

Smell/Aroma

Color

Flavor

Heat sensitivity

Affinity with food.

SMELL / AROMA

I decided to go with the Amplifier, It pushes aroma's further foward than any other glass and has the best functional swirl.

gallery_23992_4186_35978.jpg

gallery_23992_4186_17320.jpg

COLOR and FLAVOR

We used plastic inert 2 oz crytal clear cups.

Philadinings new flourescent rig highlighted the room perfectly.

gallery_23992_4186_81954.jpg

HEAT SENSITIVITY

Using a standard graduted flask, we heated up the oil with a hot air gun, temp was monitored with infra-red thermometer.

Basically compared samples of the same oils with a 20 to 30 degree difference.

Makes a big difference.

More comments about this when the "Risotto of Nothing" is discussed.

gallery_23992_4186_13312.jpggallery_23992_4186_36580.jpg

FOOD AFFINITY

We decided to see the impact of Olive oil on various types of food and assembled a variety of small tastes to see the contribution of olive oil at the end.

All dishes had olive oil added to the plate at the end.

One could then taste the dish before and after the addition of oil.

The dishes were as follows.

Onaga Ceviche. Tomato-Tarragon Sorbet. Fennel. Mint. Cilantro. Aji Panca.

gallery_23992_4186_15274.jpg

Grilled Pane Rustica. Bincho-Tan Charcoal. Pesto

gallery_23992_4186_30356.jpg

Warm Burratta. Red Orach. Sea Salt. Black Pepper

gallery_23992_4186_52309.jpg

Risotto of Nothing. Parmesan.

gallery_23992_4186_2135.jpg

Lentil Stew. Chick Pea. Iberico Chorizo, Iberico Salsichon, Finochiona, Piquillo. Esplette. Benton Bacon.

gallery_23992_4186_18059.jpg

Mozzarella Ice Cream. Black Olive Sugar.

gallery_23992_4186_41663.jpg

More Shenanigans

While the stoves were hot, we figure we would take a stab at the chicken issue.

We cooked a bluefoot and Eberly Chicken exactly the same way and did a side by side comparison.

gallery_23992_4186_37201.jpg

Everyone immediately picked the bluefoot within 3 bites.

gallery_23992_4186_67287.jpg

Chickens were both :

Breast Meat Only.

3 Grams of Maldon Salt each.

CSV with 2oz Olive Oil 58C 2 Hrs.

Seared Black Steel Pan/ Grapeseed oil.

Again, more commentary from attendees and Phil.

This was fun.

Edited by philadining (log)

"Philadelphia’s premier soup dumpling blogger" - Foobooz

philadining.com

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dang. Y'all outdid yourselves.

Next time tell me in advance, K?

Risotto of Nothing. :biggrin: I love you guys....

Katie M. Loeb
Booze Muse, Spiritual Advisor

Author: Shake, Stir, Pour:Fresh Homegrown Cocktails

Cheers!
Bartendrix,Intoxicologist, Beverage Consultant, Philadelphia, PA
Captain Liberty of the Good Varietals, Aphrodite of Alcohol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dang.  Y'all outdid yourselves.

Next time tell me in advance, K?

Risotto of Nothing. :biggrin: I love you guys....

What Katie said. Hmph.

Sandy Smith, Exile on Oxford Circle, Philadelphia

"95% of success in life is showing up." --Woody Allen

My foodblogs: 1 | 2 | 3

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...