• Welcome to the eG Forums, a service of the eGullet Society for Culinary Arts & Letters. The Society is a 501(c)3 not-for-profit organization dedicated to the advancement of the culinary arts. These advertising-free forums are provided free of charge through donations from Society members. Anyone may read the forums, but to post you must create an account.

  • product-image-quickten.png.a40203b506711f7664fc62024e54a584.pngDid you know that these all-volunteer forums are operated by the 501(c)3 not-for-profit Society for Culinary Arts & Letters? This holiday season, consider a tax-deductible Quick Ten Bucks to support the eG Forums and help us remain completely advertising-free. Thanks to all those who have donated so far!

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Fat Guy

Best Indian Food Movies

61 posts in this topic

The thread on Monsoon Wedding, and that film's neglect of all things culinary, leads me to ask: What have been the best cinematic depictions of Indian food and food rituals?


Steven A. Shaw aka "Fat Guy"
Co-founder, Society for Culinary Arts & Letters, sshaw@egstaff.org
Proud signatory to the eG Ethics code
Director, New Media Studies, International Culinary Center (take my food-blogging course)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I look forward to hearing what everyone has to say... I would love to see what films are good in dealing with food.  I am not very well versed with Bollywoof films.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well now we have Bend it Like Beckham that does talk about the food. Any others to add to this list??


Monica Bhide

A Life of Spice

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I am not very well versed with Bollywoof films.

Neither am I, I guess their woof is worse than their barf. :biggrin:


I fry by the heat of my pans. ~ Suresh Hinduja

http://www.gourmetindia.com

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bhaji on the Beach?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Interesting topic. I'm a huge fan of Bollywood films (Shawn HATES it when I play the soundtracks). I'm also a huge fan of food movies. Honestly, I think Bend It Like Beckham is about it. Most Bollywood films spend considerably more time on locale, costumes, and songs - often to the exclusion of plot...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I am not very well versed with Bollywoof films.

Neither am I, I guess their woof is worse than their barf. :biggrin:

Just when I was beginning to like you :wink: I love Bollywood movies, the new ones in particular. Most of my memories of the old ones, around food, are the mother making Indian rice pudding (Kheer)


Monica Bhide

A Life of Spice

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Interesting topic. I'm a huge fan of Bollywood films (Shawn HATES it when I play the soundtracks). I'm also a huge fan of food movies. Honestly, I think Bend It Like Beckham is about it. Most Bollywood films spend considerably more time on locale, costumes, and songs - often to the exclusion of plot...

Now books, on the other hand, talk alot about the food and that's what I love. Particularly books written by immigrants to America remembering the food.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

we need an Indian version of Eat, Drink, Man, Woman.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

first things first, "bend it like beckham" and "bhaji on the beach" are not bollywood movies. they're not even indian movies. they're british movies. nor is "monsoon wedding" a bollywood movie. it is a movie set in india by a director of indian origin starring indian actors. bollywood refers to the hindi film industry of bombay, and specificially to the popular cinema that emerges from it. there are completely different film industries in other parts of the country, and the art cinema is separate from these as well (ray in bengali--occasionally hindi as well--adoor in malayalam; mani kaul in hindi etc.); there is a middle cinema which is anchored uneasily in bollywood, and draws on the same resources--people like basu bhattacharya, sai paranjpe and ketan mehta.

speaking of ketan mehta, his great film "mirch masala" is not about food but uses chilli powder both as metaphor and thematic element.

more later on bollywood films later when i have time. but a film with extended eating scenes is the early 80s bachhan starrer: "satte pe satta"; a take on "7 brides for 7 brothers".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The thread on Monsoon Wedding, and that film's neglect of all things culinary, leads me to ask: What have been the best cinematic depictions of Indian food and food rituals?

thanks for explaining mongo, but the question itself didn't refer to bollywood movies.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The thread on Monsoon Wedding, and that film's neglect of all things culinary, leads me to ask: What have been the best cinematic depictions of Indian food and food rituals?

thanks for explaining mongo, but the question itself didn't refer to bollywood movies.

yes tryska, but as you'll see later replies referred to specific films that are not bollywood films (or even indian films) as bollywood films.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ah. i thought you were randomly yelling at people.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ah. i thought you were randomly yelling at people.

not that i have anything against random yelling but i don't think correcting inaccuracies should ever automatically be considered "yelling". people take a lot of pains to educate themselves about certain parts of the world, less so about others--and are more prone to feel hurt when someone from that part of the world points out the gaps in their knowledge--as vikram has found out on a couple of occasions :-)

along these lines i don't feel the need to be a translator or cultural ambassador every time i talk about indian things--food or otherwise. for one thing people on the french and spanish boards, for instance, don't seem to feel any pressure to explain things to a non-french or spanish audience every time they post, and i don't see why everyone on the indian forum should either--though more power to those who want to do it. everyone can do some work in finding things out--life is more satisfying that way.

there may be more americans than any other nationality on this site but this is a global site. being global in a positive sense should mean everyone can behave like egullet is located where they are and not have to translate themselves for the "real home" audience--if that makes any sense. or at least that's how i relate to the indian forum on egullet.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think what makes it a real global site is the fact that people take pains to explain what things are. We have come a long way from explaining Naans and Lassi -- but specific things should be explained.

I think you caught the techinicality on the movie scene. I was refering to movies, bollywood or otherwise, that reflect the indian culture and food. i resonate with the culture in Bend it Like B since I was raised abroad. Point taken regardless


Monica Bhide

A Life of Spice

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think you caught the techinicality on the movie scene. I was refering to movies, bollywood or otherwise, that reflect the indian culture and food. i resonate with the culture in Bend it Like B since I was raised abroad. Point taken regardless

it isn't just a "technicality"--for one thing for us to call gurinder chadha or her movies "indian" is to participate in the same narrative that right-wing british politicians do when they say indian immigrants are not really "british" but "indian". she is a south asian brit and her films reflect that. for another thing, it is important not to substitute the diaspora for india.

with these distinctions made we can consider the ways in which films by diasporic indian directors, films by bollywood directors, and films by directors from other indian cinematic traditions do or don't represent food (or anything else). if we don't make these distinctions we disrespect both the cultures in question and the intelligence of those we might seek to educate.

i'm tempted to make the hypothesis that the mass bombay cinema does not harp on food imagery because this would be extremely alienating for a large part of its audience that doesn't eat well every day. it is one thing to show wealth as aspirational but another to show actual food. but i won't make this hypothesis just yet because i suspect that the minute i do i'll remember tons of movies that do show food being lavishly cooked, eaten and thrown away (as i say that i remember "jaane bhi do yaaron" and the "thoda khao, thoda phenko" scene--suman will know what i am talking about).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
we need an Indian version of Eat, Drink, Man, Woman.

I have not seen this movie. What is it about?


Monica Bhide

A Life of Spice

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think you caught the techinicality on the movie scene. I was refering to movies, bollywood or otherwise, that reflect the indian culture and food. i resonate with the culture in Bend it Like B since I was raised abroad. Point taken regardless

it isn't just a "technicality"--for one thing for us to call gurinder chadha or her movies "indian" is to participate in the same narrative that right-wing british politicians do when they say indian immigrants are not really "british" but "indian". she is a south asian brit and her films reflect that. for another thing, it is important not to substitute the diaspora for india.

with these distinctions made we can consider the ways in which films by diasporic indian directors, films by bollywood directors, and films by directors from other indian cinematic traditions do or don't represent food (or anything else). if we don't make these distinctions we disrespect both the cultures in question and the intelligence of those we might seek to educate.

i'm tempted to make the hypothesis that the mass bombay cinema does not harp on food imagery because this would be extremely alienating for a large part of its audience that doesn't eat well every day. it is one thing to show wealth as aspirational but another to show actual food. but i won't make this hypothesis just yet because i suspect that the minute i do i'll remember tons of movies that do show food being lavishly cooked, eaten and thrown away (as i say that i remember "jaane bhi do yaaron" and the "thoda khao, thoda phenko" scene--suman will know what i am talking about).

Interesting perspective


Monica Bhide

A Life of Spice

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
we need an Indian version of Eat, Drink, Man, Woman.

I have not seen this movie. What is it about?

it's a beautiful movie monica.

Chinese - in subtitles, but ti's about a Father who's a chef, and his four grownup daughters. Essentially the father communicates with his girls over leaborate chinese dishes that he cooks for them for their weekly dinners. Their lives change, but the constant is his elaborate cooking for them. He also can't taste anything. But that's a different story arc. Visually a very lovely movie.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

'Bawarchi' starring Rajesh Khanna and Jaya Baduri comes to my mind. As far as Indian Food Movies - to the best of my knowledge, nothing comes close.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That does sound nice. I think we will rent it for the weekend.

In many of the (ahem) bollywood movies, some things to ponder --

1. The pregnant woman hankering for pickles and raw mangoes. i never had that in any of my pregnancies. Perhaps I am an anamoly!

2. I have wondered about the custom of feeding someone a spoon of yogurt with sugar just as they are leaving the house for an important task. My mom would do that for me .. does anyone know where it originated

3. the bad guys always eat non vegetarian food. That always tickles me. Why does a bad guy not want dosa!! :wink:

Amitabh Bachan is one of my favorite actors and yes, his movie that Mongo mentioned does have a fun scene with his new bride tryiing to feed him and his six siblings like human beings. too funny!

There is a lot of mention of alcohol in the movies. Always.


Monica Bhide

A Life of Spice

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
'Bawarchi' starring Rajesh Khanna and Jaya Baduri comes to my mind. As far as Indian Food Movies - to the best of my knowledge, nothing comes close.

You are right! How did I forget that. I think there is a scene where he is asked to cook something from .. oh what was it.. some exotic vegetable.. and he prepares something fantastic and surprises the whole house.. yes?


Monica Bhide

A Life of Spice

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
we need an Indian version of Eat, Drink, Man, Woman.

I have not seen this movie. What is it about?

it's a beautiful movie monica.

Chinese - in subtitles, but ti's about a Father who's a chef, and his four grownup daughters. Essentially the father communicates with his girls over leaborate chinese dishes that he cooks for them for their weekly dinners. Their lives change, but the constant is his elaborate cooking for them. He also can't taste anything. But that's a different story arc. Visually a very lovely movie.

it is an early film by ang lee, the taiwanese director of "crouching tiger" fame--part of his "food trilogy"--"pushing hands", "eat/drink" and "the wedding banquet"--all of which use food and parent/child relationships as metaphors for the relationship between tradition/modernity.

wayne wang's "dim sum" is another great immigrant food movie. much better, in my opinion, than "the joy luck club" which it anticipates in many ways.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Well now we have Bend it Like Beckham that does talk about the food. Any others to add to this list??

FWIW, the DVD of Bend It Like Beckham has a bonus segment of the director making aloo gobi under the supervision of her mother and aunt. It couldn't be funnier if it had been written.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
i'm tempted to make the hypothesis that the mass bombay cinema does not harp on food imagery because this would be extremely alienating for a large part of its audience that doesn't eat well every day. it is one thing to show wealth as aspirational but another to show actual food. but i won't make this hypothesis just yet because i suspect that the minute i do i'll remember tons of movies that do show food being lavishly cooked, eaten and thrown away (as i say that i remember "jaane bhi do yaaron" and the "thoda khao, thoda phenko" scene--suman will know what i am talking about).

When it comes to the portrayal of food in film, Bollywood's aversion is not that dissimilar to Hollywood's. Does Hollywood's audience have any issues with putting food on the table? I think it has less to do with the financial situation of the audience and more with a larger than life image these studios are perpetuating. The activities of preparing food, eating and sleeping are just too mundane for popular cinema. Have you ever seen Julia Roberts eat on film? Denzel Washington? Brad Pitt? Aamir Khan?

I haven't. Movie stars don't eat. Not publicly at least.

It's an archetypal anima/animus thing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Similar Content

    • By Phill Bernier
      Hi There,
       
      I came across this term, Bunooing, which I'd never heard before. I had a look around to try and understand the method behind it, but came across a number of inferences on what bhunooing is and how it works, some of which were conflicting and a little confusing. I would be very grateful if someone could clear this up for me and perhaps answer a few questions. This is my understanding of bhunooing so far:-
       
      Essentially, this is a method of releasing essential oils that are cooped up in your dry spices and leaves too. The types of spices used are the hard spices such as cumin seeds, cloves, cinnamon, mustard seeds etc. As I understand it powdered spice can be added, but nearer the end of the bhunooing process.
       
      The thinking behind this method is that spices take on moisture over time which dilutes the essential oils in the spices. By slow frying the spices you are gently evaporating the water and releasing the concentrated essential oils from the spice which enhances the power of spice, giving it more punch.
       
      The bhunooing process can be used to make a vibrant base for your gravy. To do this, heat a good amount of oil on high and then bring it down to a medium heat. Add your spices and onion and slowly fry until the onion turns a light brown. At this point add your liquid/ gravy.
      Some questions that I have are:-
      Why heat the oil to hot and bring to medium? Why not just heat to medium? Does bhunooing always have to include onions? The first time I tried this, the onions absorbed all of the oil after a while - is this okay? Or does it mean that I used too much oil? Is this the same, or does it have any relation to the bhuna? I have come across articles and recipes that refer to bhunooing and suggest that it's (perhaps) just the process of slow cooking ingredients on a flame/ hob - is this correct? How long should I be frying the spices for? I would be very grateful for any help you can provide.
       
      Thank you in advance
      Phill
    • By polly
      Lately i've been wondering about the use of food colouring in Indian food.
      Is there a traditional aesthetic use of it, or is it maybe to reproduce the colour that chilli powder or saffron would have given to a dish?
    • Guest nimki
      By Guest nimki
      Hi
      I just finished reading Flavours of Delhi. It was an interesting concept, though I found the descriptions too sketchy.
      Two points of note in the book -
      1) Connaught Place persistently spelt as Connuaght Place
      2) Description of Kachri as a dried melon, being used as a souring agent.
      To the best of my knowledge, and I do know about Kachris, they are small fruits (about the size of a large ber) that grow on climbers, in Haryana and Rajasthan. Both the fresh and dried kachri are eaten in different forms. The most delicious cooked chutney is made out of dried kachris and it is very popular in Haryana, though I haven't heard of it being eaten outside of the state. (It is also a bit of an acquired taste).
      Another thing I've heard described as kachri is by Punjabis. They refer to slices of baingan, dipped in a besan paste and deep fried, as Kachri.
      My question is, has anyone heard of a wild /dried or any other kind of melon called kachri?
      Or was it a factual error?
    • By Suvir Saran
      I have recently made trips to a Dosa spot that has been praised quite a lot around this site and elsewhere.
      I was terribly dissapointed.
      Dosas are one of my favorite foods. It is a pity that Indian restaurants in NYC have really not shared the magic that can come with each bite of a Dosa. Some friends of mine that have traveled to India and had loved Dosas even before making that trip, came back never wanting to eat American Indian Dosas again. There is such a marked difference.
      Why is that so? What makes them so different?
      Where do you find your favorite Dosa?
      What are you looking for in a good Dosa?
      What do you think the perfect Dosa should be like?
      What should the Sambhaar have in it? What consistency should it be?
      What should the chutney be like? What chutneys would you like to eat it with? What do you think are the authentic companions to a Dosa?
    • By TheCulinaryLibrary
      I'm thinking of buying a wet spice/curry paste grinder. Any ideas on what brands are the best?
      Premier super-g, Preethi ??
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.