Jump to content
  • Welcome to the eG Forums, a service of the eGullet Society for Culinary Arts & Letters. The Society is a 501(c)3 not-for-profit organization dedicated to the advancement of the culinary arts. These advertising-free forums are provided free of charge through donations from Society members. Anyone may read the forums, but to post you must create a free account.

Edit History

liuzhou

liuzhou

9 hours ago, Anna N said:

I had not planned on dipping into my stash of crusty goodies so soon but by 6 PM yesterday evening I realized that I was downright hungry and that I had hardly eaten anything all day. Choices. Choices. Sometimes you can have just too many of them. But the Scottish meat pie won.

 

 

42158D07-E2F2-478F-AB5A-9D595F209FBD.thumb.jpeg.effba14bb8e7963b1536725cefa2219b.jpeg

 

I reheated it at 350°F for 30 minutes. It didn’t seem to take on very much color. When I broke into it I was a little disturbed by the color. I was certain that it was beef but this looked much more like pork. I checked the ingredients and it certainly said beef.

 

C2277907-B844-4994-9B4B-F62046C3090B.thumb.jpeg.7e6404b656566abf9ab7595b3cd08a7a.jpeg

 

As. you can probably see the meat is clumpy. That’s the best word I can come up with. But despite all these apparent anomalies (as compared to my expectations), the filling was well seasoned and quite palatable. It was a little like eating meatballs though. I had hesitated initially whether I should reheat one or two of these. I am glad I opted for only one because it was very filling. 
 

C9A8E3DD-B6C6-4BBA-8141-CFC5218A09F2.thumb.jpeg.61cbf3b1d4d50b91917b73a95722f601.jpeg

 

The crust is sturdy. It’s not horrible but neither is it particularly appealing either in taste, it has very little, or texture so I did not finish the bottom casing. 
 

Overall it was nowhere near my favourite but it did have its own appeal and I will certainly eat the second one. 

 

 

Now, a proper Scotch pie (not Scottish pie, and Scotch can only be applied to foods and whisky - never to people) is not complete unless the depression on top is filled with mashed potatoes, Heinz beans or both! Some come with curry sauce - never been there. Also, they are usually made from lamb. That said it is at least 40 years since I ate any type of Scotch pie.

liuzhou

liuzhou

8 minutes ago, Anna N said:

I had not planned on dipping into my stash of crusty goodies so soon but by 6 PM yesterday evening I realized that I was downright hungry and that I had hardly eaten anything all day. Choices. Choices. Sometimes you can have just too many of them. But the Scottish meat pie won.

 

 

42158D07-E2F2-478F-AB5A-9D595F209FBD.thumb.jpeg.effba14bb8e7963b1536725cefa2219b.jpeg

 

I reheated it at 350°F for 30 minutes. It didn’t seem to take on very much color. When I broke into it I was a little disturbed by the color. I was certain that it was beef but this looked much more like pork. I checked the ingredients and it certainly said beef.

 

C2277907-B844-4994-9B4B-F62046C3090B.thumb.jpeg.7e6404b656566abf9ab7595b3cd08a7a.jpeg

 

As. you can probably see the meat is clumpy. That’s the best word I can come up with. But despite all these apparent anomalies (as compared to my expectations), the filling was well seasoned and quite palatable. It was a little like eating meatballs though. I had hesitated initially whether I should reheat one or two of these. I am glad I opted for only one because it was very filling. 
 

C9A8E3DD-B6C6-4BBA-8141-CFC5218A09F2.thumb.jpeg.61cbf3b1d4d50b91917b73a95722f601.jpeg

 

The crust is sturdy. It’s not horrible but neither is it particularly appealing either in taste, it has very little, or texture so I did not finish the bottom casing. 
 

Overall it was nowhere near my favourite but it did have its own appeal and I will certainly eat the second one. 

 

 

Now, a proper Scotch pie (not Scottish pie, although Scotch can only be applied to foods and whisky - never to people) is not complete unless the depression on top is filled with mashed potatoes, Heinz beans or both! Some come with curry sauce - never been there. Also, they are usually made from lamb. That said it is at least 40 years since I ate any type of Scotch pie.

liuzhou

liuzhou

3 minutes ago, Anna N said:

I had not planned on dipping into my stash of crusty goodies so soon but by 6 PM yesterday evening I realized that I was downright hungry and that I had hardly eaten anything all day. Choices. Choices. Sometimes you can have just too many of them. But the Scottish meat pie won.

 

 

42158D07-E2F2-478F-AB5A-9D595F209FBD.thumb.jpeg.effba14bb8e7963b1536725cefa2219b.jpeg

 

I reheated it at 350°F for 30 minutes. It didn’t seem to take on very much color. When I broke into it I was a little disturbed by the color. I was certain that it was beef but this looked much more like pork. I checked the ingredients and it certainly said beef.

 

C2277907-B844-4994-9B4B-F62046C3090B.thumb.jpeg.7e6404b656566abf9ab7595b3cd08a7a.jpeg

 

As. you can probably see the meat is clumpy. That’s the best word I can come up with. But despite all these apparent anomalies (as compared to my expectations), the filling was well seasoned and quite palatable. It was a little like eating meatballs though. I had hesitated initially whether I should reheat one or two of these. I am glad I opted for only one because it was very filling. 
 

C9A8E3DD-B6C6-4BBA-8141-CFC5218A09F2.thumb.jpeg.61cbf3b1d4d50b91917b73a95722f601.jpeg

 

The crust is sturdy. It’s not horrible but neither is it particularly appealing either in taste, it has very little, or texture so I did not finish the bottom casing. 
 

Overall it was nowhere near my favourite but it did have its own appeal and I will certainly eat the second one. 

 

 

Now, a proper Scotch pie (not Scottish pie, although Scotch can only be applied to foods and whisky - never to people) is not complete unless the depression on top is filled with mashed potatoes, Heinz beans or both! Some come with curry sauce - never been there. That said it is at least 40 years since I ate any type of Scotch pie.

×
×
  • Create New...