Jump to content
  • Welcome to the eG Forums, a service of the eGullet Society for Culinary Arts & Letters. The Society is a 501(c)3 not-for-profit organization dedicated to the advancement of the culinary arts. These advertising-free forums are provided free of charge through donations from Society members. Anyone may read the forums, but to post you must create a free account.

Smithey Ironware


rustwood

Recommended Posts

Yet another entry in the high end cast iron market.  $160 for the 10" and $200 for the 12".  They are 100% made in the USA, but so is the Marquette Castings 10.5" and that goes for ~$115 (other Marquette sizes are not made in the USA).  Suddenly I am more interested in keeping a closer eye out for nice examples of vintage cast iron. 

Edited by rustwood
clarified rambling (log)
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I didn't know for years there WAS any cast ironware other than Lodge, but I guess that comes from growing up in Tennessee. I was intrigued to see, looking at their website, that they also sell carbon steel; I had been contemplating a Darto, but now I think I'll go with a Lodge. For a Tennessean, no trip to Chattanooga is complete without a stop by the Lodge foundry in South Pittsburg. I've bought a fair number of skillets and casseroles there! 

 

ETA, I'm curious how anyone who knows would say Lodge stacks up against some of the higher-end cast iron products.

Edited by kayb (log)
  • Like 1

Don't ask. Eat it.

www.kayatthekeyboard.wordpress.com

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't understand "high end" cast iron. I appreciate that they're offering a polished product, as opposed to the sand-cast offerings from Lodge, but I'm not sure that offers any benefit. Kenji Lopez-Alt at Serious Eats reported that "bumpy" cast iron didn't differ from smooth cast iron with respect to its non-stick properties. This accords with my experience; I have two vintage cast iron pans I inherited from my grandmothers, as well as a Lodge skillet I purchased new. I haven't noticed a difference between Lodge and vintage.

 

For $20, you can get a 12" Lodge from Walmart that has an almost 5-star rating on Amazon with 10,000 user reviews. Alternatively, you could get a 12" pan from Smithey for $200 which has basically zero customer reviews. Not that I doubt its quality; it's cast iron, and cast iron performs like cast iron. I mean... I'm sure it's nice and all. But there's no reason to pay that much money for it.

  • Like 7
Link to comment
Share on other sites

... except maybe if you really like the way it looks when it is hanging in your kitchen (I guess).  I think several of these makers have touted their smooth finish.  That may be an attempt to lure the people who who have old cast iron with a smooth finish.  They often seem to view the new stuff with bumpy finishes as inferior.

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

One benefit of the older cast iron, in addition to being very smooth, is that it is a bit thinner-walled and therefore a little lighter. The Wagner-Ware I have is also more ergonomically designed than the Lodge pieces. I feel more confident flipping food or slipping a fritatta out of the classic stuff.

Edited by Lisa Shock (log)
  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, btbyrd said:

I don't understand "high end" cast iron. I appreciate that they're offering a polished product, as opposed to the sand-cast offerings from Lodge, but I'm not sure that offers any benefit. Kenji Lopez-Alt at Serious Eats reported that "bumpy" cast iron didn't differ from smooth cast iron with respect to its non-stick properties. This accords with my experience; I have two vintage cast iron pans I inherited from my grandmothers, as well as a Lodge skillet I purchased new. I haven't noticed a difference between Lodge and vintage.

 

The stickyness of my lodge skillet decreased dramatically after I took a flap disc on an angle grinder to it.  Not that I'm going to buy a $200 piece of cast iron for that, though. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Because I restore cast iron pans for a hobby I have lodge, Griswold and BSR pans. I have a made-for sears Wagner that I haven't finished restoring. Griswold is lighter, and I like the finish of the bare metal as manufactured. It just seasons up better. My large Lodge is heavy and the finish just isn't there.

 

I can't imagine shelling out the big bucks for today's heavy pans no matter what finish they claim.

Edited by Porthos
Missing word (log)
  • Like 3

Porthos Potwatcher
The Once and Future Cook

;

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Smithey pricing is outrageous — but not as outrageous as that of Borough Furnace.

Vintage pieces are often available for a pittance

  • Like 1

~Martin :)

I just don't want to look back and think "I could have eaten that."

Unsupervised, rebellious, radical agrarian experimenter, minimalist penny-pincher, and adventurous cook. Crotchety, cantankerous, terse curmudgeon, non-conformist, and contrarian who questions everything!

The best thing about a vegetable garden is all the meat you can hunt and trap out of it!

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, DiggingDogFarm said:

Smithey pricing is outrageous — but not as outrageous as that of Borough Furnace.

Vintage pieces are often available for a pittance

 

'I want something like the Braising Skillet on the Borough Furnace page, but not for that kind of $$$. Anyone seen something similar elsewhere?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

34 minutes ago, quiet1 said:

 

'I want something like the Braising Skillet on the Borough Furnace page, but not for that kind of $$$. Anyone seen something similar elsewhere?

 

Lodge makes one but it's a bit bigger.

~Martin :)

I just don't want to look back and think "I could have eaten that."

Unsupervised, rebellious, radical agrarian experimenter, minimalist penny-pincher, and adventurous cook. Crotchety, cantankerous, terse curmudgeon, non-conformist, and contrarian who questions everything!

The best thing about a vegetable garden is all the meat you can hunt and trap out of it!

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...