• Welcome to the eG Forums, a service of the eGullet Society for Culinary Arts & Letters. The Society is a 501(c)3 not-for-profit organization dedicated to the advancement of the culinary arts. These advertising-free forums are provided free of charge through donations from Society members. Anyone may read the forums, but to post you must create an account.

paulraphael

ziplocks for cook-chill sous vide

25 posts in this topic

Dave Arnold and co. say yes, Nathan Myrhvold and co. say no.

 

Dave makes a good case for it and says that 90% of sous-vide cooking can be done without a vacuum, and that his food saver has been relegated to re-sealing potato chips. Nathan doesn't give a reason.

 

I don't understand why ziplocks couldn't be used for cook-chill applications. Don't we use them to store conventionally cooked food in the fridge?

 

Thoughts? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with you and Arnold.

 

Only argument I can think of is that the zip loc might open in the fridge.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Where does Myhrvold say no? From what I remember, he says you eliminate oxidation using vacuum bags which can increase keeping quality of cook chill foods. When you have a bajillion chamber vacuums like him, this is a no-brainer and he does stuff like chamber vac beans and water to hydrate them instead of just putting them in a bowl like a normal person.

 

For everyone else, just use ziplocks and don't think about it.


PS: I am a guy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I cook with sous vide bags, un-sealed.

 

It is very nice that I can taste test while the food is being cooked and adjust seasoning if required. For large piece of meat I can even probe temperature once in a while.

 

After cooking, I rinse the bags, turn them inside out and store them. After I have lots of them, I throw them in the clothes washer and they come out totally clean and good for the next round of cooking.

 

Bags are not cheap, and it take time to seal/unseal.

 

dcarch.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Have a picture of the way you do it, Dcarch?

 

I'm trying to visualize an unsealed vacuum bag that isn't filled with air.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been using zip locks for years with no problems - even with cook chill.  That being said, here and there I've had a problem once in a while with doing high temp stuff in a ziplock - like a confit at 176 for several hours - here and there one bag would leak.  But for most things, especially below say 150degF I've had no problems, and it's much more convenient.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Where does Myhrvold say no? From what I remember, he says you eliminate oxidation using vacuum bags which can increase keeping quality of cook chill foods. When you have a bajillion chamber vacuums like him, this is a no-brainer and he does stuff like chamber vac beans and water to hydrate them instead of just putting them in a bowl like a normal person.

 

For everyone else, just use ziplocks and don't think about it.

 

I agree with you based on what I know. But Myhrvold does say otherwise.

 

 

“Strictly speaking, vacuum packing is only required (as a safety measure and to prevent oxidation) for cook-chill sous vide, in which the food is stored after cooking.”
 
and
 
“Zip closure bags are inexpensive and available at any corner store. Althought not suitable for cook-chill sous-vide, they can work well in a pinch for improvising sous-vide packaging”
 
I'm curious if there's any substance behind this. Might be that as you suggest, life without a vacuum machine is hust not a life he's ever imagined.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd suggest it hinges on how reliable the seal is.  With a chamber/FoodSaver, sealing involves essentially melting teh two sides of the bag into a single layer.  Ziplocs are good, but can potentially come unsealed under conditions where the temperature, and thus 'direction' of any pressure differential, are changing rapidly.  As when you put a hot bag in a bowl of ice and water.


Leslie Craven, aka "lesliec"
Host, eG Forumslcraven@egstaff.org

After a good dinner one can forgive anybody, even one's own relatives ~ Oscar Wilde

My eG Foodblog

eGullet Ethics Code signatory

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I cook with sous vide bags, un-sealed.

 

It is very nice that I can taste test while the food is being cooked and adjust seasoning if required. For large piece of meat I can even probe temperature once in a while.

 

After cooking, I rinse the bags, turn them inside out and store them. After I have lots of them, I throw them in the clothes washer and they come out totally clean and good for the next round of cooking.

 

Bags are not cheap, and it take time to seal/unseal.

 

dcarch.

 

I can't see doing this.  Bags seal in well less than a minute, and take seconds to cut open.  It costs $2.00, in quarters, for me to do a load of wash.  New bags are 20 cents a piece, and I don't have to go out in the snow.

 

If I had a washing machine in my kitchen rather than a chamber vacuum sealer I might feel differently.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Notice that Dave Arnold says, towards the bottom of the linked article, that one of the disadvantages of ziplocs is that they don't permit the same extended storage as vacuum bags.  Frustratingly, he never says how long he thinks ziplocs are okay for cook-chill, so the advice isn't very useful.  Personally I'd hesitate to rely on ziplocs for holding any longer than open leftovers (three days to a week, depending on fridge temp).  My experience with ziplocs when used for general storage (don't do cook-chill) is that they allow in air rather easily over a period of days even without the seal failing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Notice that Dave Arnold says, towards the bottom of the linked article, that one of the disadvantages of ziplocs is that they don't permit the same extended storage as vacuum bags.  Frustratingly, he never says how long he thinks ziplocs are okay for cook-chill, so the advice isn't very useful.  Personally I'd hesitate to rely on ziplocs for holding any longer than open leftovers (three days to a week, depending on fridge temp).  My experience with ziplocs when used for general storage (don't do cook-chill) is that they allow in air rather easily over a period of days even without the seal failing.

 

Isn't a week as long as you'd ever do cook-chill?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Am.Test Kitchen did a 'study' of plastic storage bags for the freezer.  zip-loc's, zip-loc's w the extraction hole if you will, regular plastic

 

Food saver and the Weston ( 400 $$ ) system.

 

they found that after  ( paraphrasing here ) 1 - 2 months in the freezer ice crystals in the bag penetrated the plastic and the contents were t

 

then subjected to 'freezer burn'

 

the Weston system w the thicker 3.5 MIL bags did not do this and lasted .....

 

I got the Weston system 3 years ago or so to begin my SV studies.  none of these bags have failed me after I understood how clean and 

 

dry  the bags needed to be at the seal.

 

Ive had stuff SV in my freezer thats over a year old:  seal good, tastes fine.

 

so   cooking and saving for a brief period of time is one thing, freezing for a long time is another.

 

i also store my green coffee beans this way, but not in the freezer:  just a very cold basement.

 

so the thickness of the bag will determine who long the contents might keep,   + / -

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can't see doing this.  Bags seal in well less than a minute, and take seconds to cut open.  It costs $2.00, in quarters, for me to do a load of wash.  New bags are 20 cents a piece, and I don't have to go out in the snow.

 

If I had a washing machine in my kitchen rather than a chamber vacuum sealer I might feel differently.

 

As I said in the above post, there are more reason than just $. In any case, I use boil-able heavy duty bags which are $0.40 each. And recycling means a lot to me.

 

Shopping, buying takes time too.

 

dcarch

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Have a picture of the way you do it, Dcarch?

 

I'm trying to visualize an unsealed vacuum bag that isn't filled with air.

 

Sure. Also someone had asked about how I weigh my bags down.

 

dcarch

 

bagweight_zps24a71d54.jpg

 

bagweight2_zpsbe4f4fc9.jpg

 

bagweight3_zpsc9417034.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Looks like a lot of air in the bag.

 

How do you deal with that? Fill the bag with fluid?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Looks like a lot of air in the bag.

 

How do you deal with that? Fill the bag with fluid?

 

There will be very little, if any, air inside.

 

The bag will have some marinade, seasoning, or sauce. The meat will give out some juice once heated. The hot water softens the plastic bag, and the heavy weigh holds down the bag to allow hydro-static pressure to squeeze out the air.

 

dcarch

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Isn't a week as long as you'd ever do cook-chill?

Baldwin gives cook-chill times up to 90 days for very cold storage, presumably for vacuum bags though it's not expressly stated.  Indeed, in my understanding, this was one of the main advantages of sous vide when first developed as a commercial process.  Anyhoo, circling back to the OP, if you're only looking to hold for a week, I think even Nathan would agree ziplocs are okay.

 

And, gfweb, as for your question to dcarch, bear in mind that pressure from the water will evacuate the air, just as when loading ziplocs.  So long as the food stays below the water line, there's no way for the air above to get at it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As I said in the above post, there are more reason than just $. In any case, I use boil-able heavy duty bags which are $0.40 each. And recycling means a lot to me.

 

Shopping, buying takes time too.

 

dcarch

 

If you are going to wash the bags I don't see why you could not reseal and reuse the same bag several times.  The 20 cent bags are boilable.  If your bags are retort bags that could be used in a pressure cooker I would probably be interested to buy some.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've done a lot of experiments with sealing in Ziploc bags.....they're not dependable in terms of staying sealed and some folks consider them quite permeable.

If you want to cook-chill foods with confidence....use better bags.


~Martin

Unsupervised rebellious radical agrarian experimenter, minimalist penny-pincher, self-reliant homesteader and adventurous cook. Crotchety cantankerous terse curmudgeon, nonconformist, contrarian and natural born skeptic who questions everything!

The best thing about a vegetable garden is all the meat you can hunt and trap out of it! 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Frustratingly, he never says how long he thinks ziplocs are okay for cook-chill, so the advice isn't very useful.  

 

Some Ziplocs stay sealed well for an extended period of time and some don't so it's impossible to honestly estimate how long they'll stay sealed.


~Martin

Unsupervised rebellious radical agrarian experimenter, minimalist penny-pincher, self-reliant homesteader and adventurous cook. Crotchety cantankerous terse curmudgeon, nonconformist, contrarian and natural born skeptic who questions everything!

The best thing about a vegetable garden is all the meat you can hunt and trap out of it! 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are going to wash the bags I don't see why you could not reseal and reuse the same bag several times.  The 20 cent bags are boilable.  If your bags are retort bags that could be used in a pressure cooker I would probably be interested to buy some.

I guess you are still missing part of what I said above"----It is very nice that I can taste test while the food is being cooked and adjust seasoning if required. For large piece of meat I can even probe temperature once in a while.---"

 

Each time you cut and seal, the bags get smaller, soon I will have close to a hundred bags of various sizes to manage. I have found that the cheaper bags have the problem of the "quilted" layer delaminating after a few cooks.

 

darch

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe I am missing something else, but if you are not using an edge sealer, why use quilted bags at all?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd love to see some experimental evidence on foods cooked to pasteurization in ziplock freezer bags and stored at a range of standard fridge temperatures. 

Not really a home experiment. You'd want lots of samples, a few different types of food, and a range of fridge temperatures. Real life fridges add a lot of variables with their temperature swings.

And you'd need a biology lab, and some agreed-upon standards.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe I am missing something else, but if you are not using an edge sealer, why use quilted bags at all?

 

A very good question.

 

1. I do, very seldom, vacuum and seal. Although I don't remember when was the last time.

 

2. I trust more the plastic used for boil-able  bags specifically designed for high temperature sous vide water baths. I made clotted cream yeaterday, at 180F for 10 hours.

 

3. And this unique use I came up with. As I said, I am interested in recycling and re-purposing materials.

 

 

dcarch

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd love to see some experimental evidence on foods cooked to pasteurization in ziplock freezer bags and stored at a range of standard fridge temperatures. 

Not really a home experiment. You'd want lots of samples, a few different types of food, and a range of fridge temperatures. Real life fridges add a lot of variables with their temperature swings.

And you'd need a biology lab, and some agreed-upon standards.

 

To my knowledge, no such study has been done, which may expain why Dave Arnold was so vague.  But, again, if you're only looking to hold for a week, existing food handling protocols say that's okay, so long as the temp stays below 41F.  See FDA Food Code, § 3‑501.17(A)(1) (scroll down the page about two-thirds of the way).  Whether your fridge actually holds this temp is the bigger issue.  I monitor mine with a thermometer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Similar Content

    • By bhsimon
      Anyone tried this?
       
      I'm trying to think of something novel to do for my friends at an upcoming birthday weekend. We are renting a house in the Hunter Valley (Australian wine region) and food is a major component of our weekend. Last time I did fizzy fruit—the grapes and oranges were awesome and everyone enjoyed the unique experience. I want to do something quirky like that again.
       
      The whipping siphon is easy to transport so I'm interested in using it. The siphoned soufflé in Modernist Cuisine, volume 4 page 297, has a chocolate variation that does not require propylene glycol alginate or maltodextrin (I don't have those things in my pantry, yet). That looks like it might be a good one to try. Anyone done that and have some advice for me before I dive in?
    • By bhsimon
      Besides the health concerns, deep frying steak is the best way to get an even colour and crust on steak. In my most recent experiment, I tried the technique of deep frying prior to, and after, cooking the steak sous vide. In the past, I had only fried the meat after it had been cooked.
       
      The meat was veal chops. As can often be the case, the meat was mishandled somewhere along the way. The obvious signs of this were indentations in the surface. This kind of thing makes it tricky to pan fry and get even colour.
       


       
      This soft meat is also tricky to vacuum seal as it can often be further compressed and misshapen in the process.
       
      I was delighted to observe that a short 45 seconds in hot oil fixed both of these issues! I didn't expect that. Nice. The meat plumped up and that indentation was gone. It also held its shape nicely when vacuum packed.
       

       
      Time and temperature matters. The difference can be just a few seconds or degrees. In the next picture, the time was the same but the oil was 20°C hotter for the steak on the left and the crust is noticeably darker. My next experiment will try 30 seconds at 200°C before and after.
       


      The goal is to keep the crust as thin as possible.
       

       
      I hadn't anticipated the secondary benefits of deep frying prior to sous vide. The plumping of the meat and slight firmness made them easy to package and present. I am curious whether anyone has observed this. I am also curious if it would it work in hot water, rather than oil.



    • By Porthos
      I have purchased an Anova circulator. My interest in sous vide is based upon needing to prepare chicken and pork dishes that remain more moist than other cooking methods I have used. This is based upon needing more moistness for my wife. After her bariactric surgery she became sensitive to meat that is not still very moist.
       
      I would like recommendations for some threads to read through to help get me started.
    • By Adamsm83
      So I did a quick search for a SV whole prime rib and everything I found just turned into, "why waste your time? Just roast it!" Which I would generally agree with, but the kitchen I work in only has one oven that can't be tied up long enough to do the prime rib, so I found a couple of recipes out there and I think my recipe will be as follows...
      Cut a 10# prime rib in half and salt and pepper the outside.
      Vaccum seal each 5# roast and SV at 137 degrees for 10hours.
      Remove from the bags. Pat dry, rub all over with roasted garlic puree, chopped rosemary, thyme & pepper.
      Roast in a 500 degree oven until dark brown.
       
      Now here is where things get tricky, I want to hold it under a banquette heat lamp during service and cut to order (like you used to see at every home town restaurant in the 90's) So my questions are, 1, is it safe? I realize that the SV and the oven should be safe, but then it sits out , although under a heat lamp, lets face it, they aren't great. Still if it sits from 5 to 9 and is gone by 9 then its okay to be in the danger zone since it will be gone in 4 hours anyways (assuming we sell out or throw out left overs. 2, what would my expected yield be after SV. I read you have a loss of approx. 20% when roasting, less if its bone-in, so SV w/ bones what are your opinions? And lastly, what are peoples opinions about the flavor profile of SV beef on the bone. 
       
      Other info to consider, i will be using a very fresh, very local beef that is grass fed up to 600# and finished on brewers grains. The meat has a very rich flavor, not overly irony, but still much more "meaty, beefy" flavor than the crap at the super markets. 
      Anyways, I would like to get this thing rolling next week, so any helpful tips, tricks or advice would be much appreciated. Thanks!
    • By Morkai
      I am planning on making Michael Ruhlman's macaroni and cheese this weekend for a party. In the recipe, you make a soubise sauce with flour, butter, milk, and carmelized onions. You hand blend these all together (with some spices), and then add the grated cheese to the hot liquid to melt. Then you can mix in with the cooked pasta and keep overnight in the fridge.
       
      Then I remembered I have sodium citrate in the pantry. 
       
      We like this recipe, but find that it's not as "cheesy" or "creamy" as we'd like it to be sometimes, especially after cooking. Would adding a dash of sodium citrate to the cheese/soubise mixture help keep it that classic cheesy texture? Even if it sat overnight in the fridge and was then baked? As I am making this along with smoking a couple pork butts for my girlfriend's co-workers, I really don't want to have a food disaster! 
       
      Thanks all,
       
      Mork
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.