The active discussion thread for Jean Georges and Nougatine may be found here. We returned to Jean=Georges last night. Bar area was v. crowded and noisey, the diningroom full & noisey. Service was very good. All 4 guests had the tasting menus. We Left feeling that the restaurant had lost its edge. The signature 'egg' was runny, without even soft curds. The terrine of foie gras was over wrought w. a candy-pistachio wafer ["ice] & pistachio cream on the plate. The chestnut broth was delicious but the mushroom ravioli, tasteless. The fish had a dense, hard crust of seeds. The succulent lobster morsel was overwhelmed by the tamarind sauce and the venison was simply subpar, both grainy and lacking taste. Did we hit an off night ---albeit a rather expensive one-- or is this restaurant on the down slope?