I'd noticed that mine was reading about .6f lower than my non-thermopen fast digital thermometer... which is close enough for me, then I got a second anova yesterday, and notice that they're both reading about .6f lower than my digital... either both my anovas are off by the same amount, or it's the thermometer. I suggest getting a second (third?) opinion. Thermapen accuracy specs: ±0.7°F (±0.4°C) from -58 to 392°F http://www.thermoworks.com/products/thermapen/#Specifications Well, 1.2 is more than the listed accuracy window. And the thermapen registers a perfect 32 F when I follow the calibration steps they recommend (crushed ice with cold water to cover, stick in the pen and stir, etc.) I guess another possible test would be to set it to 99 C and see if the water boils (shouldn't).