Jump to content

Coop

participating member
  • Posts

    1,209
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Coop

  1. I just keep re-reading Mr Heather's post, and I still can't believe he told some of us not to darken his doors ever again. I keep thinking he would edit that part out of his post but it's still there. I don't think any part of this will cause his business as much damage as his own post. Just my opinion from a distance.

  2. I have never been to any of Sean's restaurants or have I participated in any DOV events this year. I have a big problem with what is being said in these threads.

    First off I think the Irish Heather has probably come out well ahead monetarily because of e gullet. I think the buzz the restaurant has recieved here far out wieghs the harm a few negative posts could cause. It's obvious that people tried your place because you joined this community. I think it's wonderful that you have made all this effort to focus on food in your establishment.

    That being said I believe that the people who posted about thier poor experiences meant you no malice. I think they were being honest. In the past I may have done the same thing. Now I would temper my displeasure because I know the pain it can cause a chef or owner.

    In terms of being anonymus I have always signed my posts and most people on this board have met me personally. If anyone ever has a problem with my posts you all basically know where to find me. I have a real problem with the way you have charicterised some of the posters here. I hope you aren't that way with all of your customers. I fear you probably are.

    If this becomes a place where customers square off against people of the industry we all know who has the most to loose. In conclusion if I do ever end up at your place and you decide to comment on my drinking habits like you did above then we will have a real problem.

  3. I was indeed a punk. Still am in a under cover sort of way. I think most people my age who had thier share of disco and pop became punks and whatever that was that followed. I wish I had more to add to this thread but bars just aren't my thing anymore. Vintropolis seemed okay the one time I went there. I also love Subeez. They have decent food, Full Sail IPA and a pretty pumping sound system. Could use a cleaning though.

  4. For me numerical vintage ratings are as dangerous as wine scores. Try a couple of different bottles and see what's in the bottle. I know in one case 2002 Crognolo (from Sette Ponti in Tuscany) has recieved excellent notes because the selection was very strict so there was no Oreno. Same thing at Belguardo. So village wine in the rhone may be acceptable while the greater cru may be poor or non existent.

  5. No it probably won't suck. If it's like 2002 in Tuscany it was very wet. Selection of grapes was very important. If the price is right try a bottle. Be careful about putting away wines from this vintage. The only 2002 wine from the Rhone I remember having was a Vacuerayas from Perrin and it was very nice. just a little lighter then the 2001.

  6. Buy a book, open a bottle, make some notes. Repeat regularly. I have been for about 25 years now.

    Recomended reading:

    Adventures on the Wine Trail by Kermit Lynch.

    Michael Broadbents pocket Wine Tasting Guide.

    Wine Spectator. I don't believe everything I read in this bi weekly but it's a good read.

    Gambero Rosso if you dig Italian wine.

    Some sort of wine atlas is a great idea, it's all about terroir.

  7. I don't get it. If I go to a place and it sucks, why would I go back? Why would I not share this experience with my fellow e gullet members? Sometimes I hesitate to really flame a place here because I feel for the people and what they have invested in their restaurant. If we are all going to walk on egg shells here we will soon become pointless.

×
×
  • Create New...