lemonice1

The food was excellent. We tried the honey vodka (great), and we had the duck which was great as well.

She said YES!!! I wanted to thank all of you for your thoughtful responses. We went to Firebird for dinner (amazing decor) and afterwards went upstairs to the parlor bar. I got down on one knee, popped the question and she said "OH MY GOD" (over and over and over), then she said YES!!! And we lived happily ever after (it's been a week now). Thanks again for your help.

Thanks everyone for the replies! I was out-of-town for the weekend and couldn't respond. Being a poor college student, I'd like to spend roughly 贶 or so. Could be a little more depending on how much money I have at the time. We don't drink much so drinks aren't a problem. I'm leaning towards proposing towards the end or possibly after dinner while still at the restaurant. I want her to remember the nice dinner and we probably wouldn't even finish dinner if I proposed during. I'm leaning towards going to Firebird, it seemed like a really cool setting. I'm certainly open to some more suggestions though, since we aren't going for another 6 weeks. Thanks everyone!

Hi everyone! I'm surprising my girl on Dec 14 to 16 and flying us up to NYC from Orlando. She's never been before and I haven't been since I was 10 so we're going to see the city and go to the Radio City Christmas show. I want to propose while up there and thought maybe during or at the end of a dinner. I'll be a recent college grad (age 24) and spent a lot of cash on the ring and trip so the dinner needs to be reasonably priced.. not too outrageous. Any other romantic spots in NY would also be appreciated! Like I said, I haven't been to NYC in ages and could use all the help I can get. Thanks for your responses!!