ISO: The Ultimate Choc. Chip & PB Cookies in Pastry & Baking Posted February 13, 2006 Just wanted to let anyone who remembers my search for chewy peanut butter cookies that I took the last bag of cookies (made and frozen mid November) for Super Bowl Sunday and they were fantastic. Still chewy and had lots of peanut butter flavor. I was really thrilled. I have found my peanut butter cooky!!!